5 ms·
What this says to me is don't bother trying to super overclock a i9-9940X, Intel has already skimmed off the cream from that chip run. It seems kind of scummy,
by jandrese 8y ago
What this says to me is don't bother trying to super overclock a i9-9940X, Intel has already skimmed off the cream from that chip run.
It seems kind of scummy, but I guess otherwise your rare stable overclock chip might end up in some boring business server where it will always run at stock clocks. I do note that Intel still wants nothing to do with overclocked chips in their warranty department, even when they did the overclocking themselves.
- gruez 8y ago>It seems kind of scummy how is it scummy? is because intel's efficiently allocating those CPUs (via auction market), rather than randomly giving them out?
- tomc1985 8y agoAn economist might call it efficient, but most would call it greed
- perl4ever 8y agoI have come around to the belief that economically efficient behavior can be more ethical. When I have something I want to get rid of, I have tried giving it away, but I learned by experience that people who are first to grab something aren't necessarily those who will make the best use of it or who need it the most. So it may be better for society to sell or auction it even if that has significant overhead. Raising more money isn't even the point; it's a side effect.
- geezerjay 8y agoMost would call it completely fair, and a proper incentive to bring similar products to market. It seems to me that greed is a problem affecting those who want it all, particularly luxury items, while complaining that they should be exempt from paying any cost.
- qeternity 8y agoGreed is good.
- samplatt 8y agoIt's (a little bit) scummy, because they're selling them on auction, which has a decent chance of flogging them for orders of magnitude more than they'd ordinarily sell them for, with the added bonus that they don't have to honor any warranty stuff since they're going to be clocked to hell.
- geezerjay 8y ago> It's (a little bit) scummy, because they're selling them on auction, which has a decent chance of flogging them for orders of magnitude more than they'd ordinarily sell them for, It seems to me that demand is far higher than supply, thus the auction ensures that those who really want them will have a realistic shot of getting one. That's far better than having to resort to buying them from price-gouging scalpers.
- Nullabillity 8y agoBuying it at inflated prices from Intel effectively rewards them for their inability to produce more. That seems like the wrong incentive to set.
- artemonster 8y agoyou have no idea how chip manufacturing works, do you? :) its a gamble for them to get such chips
- Nullabillity 8y ago> its a gamble for them to get such chips Hardly, since the "rejects" will just be sold as the regular model(s). In the old "lottery" system the rejects would end up on the secondary market, making Intel's final revenue effectively the same as if extreme overclocking wasn't a thing.
- geezerjay 8y ago> Buying it at inflated prices from Intel effectively rewards them for their inability to produce more. For this assertion to make any sense you'd need to believe that they don't benefit by increasing sales of a product line, particularly when they increase prices.
- jandrese 8y agoIt feels like when you learn that Ticketmaster also owns most of the scalping services and your chance of getting a good ticket is zero unless you're willing to go to the scalpers. Basically the good stuff is reserved for the rich because they are rich.
- gruez 8y ago>It feels like when you learn that Ticketmaster also owns most of the scalping services and your chance of getting a good ticket is zero unless you're willing to go to the scalpers. If anything, this situation is better than Ticketmaster's, because at least the producers are getting the money. With Ticketmaster, they're pocketing all the money and the performers are getting nothing. If Intel isn't binning these, a third party (probably someone affiliated with an OEM) would be doing this and pocketing the difference. >Basically the good stuff is reserved for the rich because they are rich. Are you also upset that you can't get luxury goods for cheap because they're "reserved" for the rich?
- jdietrich 8y agoSpecialist retailers and integrators have been super-binning chips for years. Intel are just taking a piece of that pie.
- microcolonel 8y agoOr, more charitably, they are integrating that. In some industries, these high binned chips are a crucial competitive advantage, and I don't see any reason why they shouldn't validate the performance of each chip they sell (at least in HEDT, other product lines I can see having little or negative return from an approach like that). Maybe they could even just make it explicit for all their products: market them by die type, configuration, and peak stable base clock.
- j-c-hewitt 8y agoThat wouldn't make that much sense at that number given that such a large percentage of recent chips have been good enough to make it to 5.0 ghz+ according to these statistics recorded by Silicon Lottery: https://siliconlottery.com/pages/statistics https://siliconlottery.com/pages/statistics -- no stats for i9-9990XE but there's enough to get an idea. It wouldn't be that shocking if delays keep hitting on the new product line that they just skim the top 30% of chips and call it a "new" product though, which would be both really funny and almost immediately noticed. But overall this kind of thing is inevitable given the giant difference between what these kinds of processors run at stock and what people who are eager to buy a top of the line processor are actually going to want to run it at.
- mschaef 8y ago> Intel has already skimmed off the cream from that chip run. ... It seems kind of scummy, This is just Intel identifying a market and a way to serve it, in order to make some money. They're a business. It's what they do.