6 ms·
It wasn't entirely clear how strongly this would invalidate conclusions drawn from a belief it was matrilinial descent only. For instance, is this enough to tot
by ggm 8y ago
It wasn't entirely clear how strongly this would invalidate conclusions drawn from a belief it was matrilinial descent only. For instance, is this enough to totally wreck the single-eve hypothesis? Or, change some of the patterns of human dispersion models? Or the neanderthal-sapiens crossbreeding?
- dogma1138 8y agoLikely not since this still seems to be extremely rare and only happen when things don’t go according to plan at least in humans. But it does indicate that more research is needed to understand the implications of this, especially on genetic screenings. Also mitochondrial eve isn’t a hypothesis, but rather stub for the most recent common genetic ancestor of modern humans before the divergence of the mitochondrial DNA groups. Also it’s important to note that mitochondrial eve isn’t a “fixed individual” in say 50,000 years the mitochondrial eve candidate would be shifted to someone who lived well pass the current one as lineages die out.
- sjburt 8y agoAlso, the application of "mitochondrial" to the common female ancestor is somewhat spurious. There is a common male ancestor as well. And if mitochondria did not exist, there would still be a common female ancestor. The mitochondria connection is just that it's a tool that can be used to estimate the time and location of that ancestor. She would not have been the only human alive at that time and there was nothing special about her mitochondria.
- brians 8y agoNo, there’s not necessarily a single common female human ancestor. There might be several of related, but not reliably interfertile, species. The most recent common ancestor in that case might be quite nonhuman, though presumably a primate.
- amluto 8y agoIt’s not obvious to me that there needs to be a common matrilineal ancestor that is even remotely like a human.
- danieltillett 8y agoIn theory it doesn’t, but because the effective population size of humans until recently has been very small, the probability is very high that the last common maternal ancestor lived relatively recently. An interesting aside is everyone who lived more than 2000 years ago is either your ancestor or has no living descendant. This wasn’t true before 1803 because the Tasmanian aborigines had been genetically isolated since the end of the last ice age [0]. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_colonisation_of_Tasmania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_colonisation_of_Tasman...
- BurningFrog 8y agoI really don't think my two Swedish farmer stock parents had massive African, Native American and Asian heritage. 23andMe didn't mention that either.
- jobigoud 8y agoIs this saying that every single human living today has dna from every ethnic group that is still around? I find it hard to believe.
- danieltillett 8y agoYes and no. Just by the time you get back 2000 years you have so many ancestors that you are related to everybody alive. There are no isolated human populations so everybody is related to everyone else. Actually you only have around 1000 effective ancestors from that time as you don't inherit DNA from every ancestor.
- jobigoud 8y ago
- waserwill 8y agoInvalidating conclusions: not particularly; these results suggest that under rare circumstances (in a few sorts of mitochondrial disease), mitochondria can be transmitted paternally. It makes the matrilineal model slightly less definitive, but, overwhelming often, accurate (note that people with mitochondrial diseases rarely exhibit this feature, and are less likely to reproduce anyway due to the disease). Single Eve: still holds; given the small population size of humans in the past, at some point there was a female ancestral to us all, as other lineages would have stochastically died out. Human dispersal and Neanderthal-modern human crosses: both have been examined via autosomal DNA. Reconstructions of dispersal may be skewed in the following manner: since we use X- Y- and mtDNA to look as sex ratios of admixture events (such as in modern Caribbean populations, where there is more European male influence and African/Native American female contribution), our reconstruction may be skewed by these selection due to incompatibilities. We expect there to have been some incompatibilities between modern humans and Neanderthals/Denisovans—no doubt some were mitochondrial. But autosomal DNA bears the evidence of our admixture. Likely some lineages (including those with prehistoric-human mt- and Y-DNA) were lost, either due to selection, stochasticity, or likely, both.
- Cacti 8y agoDoesn’t the paper specifically say that they really have no idea of the impact because not enough attention has been paid to determine the amount of paternal inheritance? You sound awfully sure of yourself considering maternal inheritance of mtDNA has been practically gospel for 50 years.
- eftychis 8y agoI agree. I wouldn't rush to draw any conclusions, as this paper changes the status quo. We can not say anything about the rarity of transmission events in the past really. This work is focused particularly on heteroplasmy -- it doesn't rule out other causes. It does not seem we understand the mitochondrial inheritance mechanism during conception.
- samatman 8y ago
- pryce 8y agoThese are good questions that will definitely need to provoke further investigation. They'd be out of the scope of this article because the news of paternal mtDNA transmission really is that fresh.