3 ms·
To what extent could PG&E mitigate these problems with improved safely devices? There are various devices that can try to minimize arcing when there is a fault
by amluto 8y ago
To what extent could PG&E mitigate these problems with improved safely devices? There are various devices that can try to minimize arcing when there is a fault, for example Petersen coils. [0]
California already has a distinct advantage here compared to the rest of the country. In the other 49 states (to the best of my knowledge), it's legal for the utilities to use a conductor that is grounded at multiple locations as a neutral. This type of arrangement induces nasty currents through the ground (which is, I think, why it's illegal in CA -- those currents can apparently be quite harmful to livestock that are being milked with metallic equipment, not to mention hazardous to people in swimming pools and such). But it also means that, if another phase shorts to ground, then there is necessarily a large amount of fault current available.
In CA, the distribution wires can't legally have any intentional current flowing between themselves and ground, which means circuits that detect residual current will work.
[0] https://www.modernpowersystems.com/features/featurenew-roles-for-the-recloser-in-the-modern-mv-network-4928052/ https://www.modernpowersystems.com/features/featurenew-roles...
- cududa 8y agoMaintaining the equipments integrity and trimming trees seems like a good start
- lisper 8y agoThey do. I'm a PH&E customer living in a woodsy area, and they trim our trees regularly.
- lutorm 8y agoThe US uses overhead wires everywhere, because it's cheaper to install than underground wires. But then you're subject to damage from trees, wind, icing, etc. Everyone pays in worse uptime, and apparently also in fire risk.
- oh_sigh 8y agoNo, not everywhere. Most of NYC uses underground wires. My neighborhood in Colorado near Boulder built in the 60s uses underground wires as well.
- mschuster91 8y agoUnderground wiring is far more efficient in big cities, as the major cost part is "miles of trench digged" and in a city the ratio of "customers per mile" is waaaay higer than in rural areas, thus reducing "investment per customer". In addition this wiring is at the maximum 110 kV, you do NOT want a 380 kV feed in a major city. These things require a shitload of clearance, talk about 40m wide and 4m deep trenches!
- amluto 8y agoThere is no fundamental reason that a tree hitting an overhead wire needs to make a giant arc. Sure, fancy protection equipment in a substation is expensive, but long distance underground wiring is very expensive. Also, IIUC, underground wiring has much higher capacitance per unit length, which can be an issue.
- Johnny555 8y agoIs the overall uptime really worse? (I'm really asking, I don't know the answer to that question) Overhead wiring is more prone to failure, but faster to fix -- a car knocked down a power pole in my street, in a few hours, the utility replaced it with a new one and strung up new wires. In contrast, a construction crew drove a pipe through an underground power line near work, it took nearly 2 days and a street closure before they restored power. Much of california is prone to earthquakes, I'm not sure whether overhead or underground power would fare better in a quake.