2 ms·
Fair? Perhaps not line for line. But it's not important at that level of detail. My point is, I think if you asked most people "Who invented the MP3 player?" t
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
Fair? Perhaps not line for line. But it's not important at that level of detail.
My point is, I think if you asked most people "Who invented the MP3 player?" they'd say Apple. That's just not the case. Refined it? Yes, obviously. But they certainly weren't first.
Long to short, execution matters. There a tons of ideas sitting in the idea gravy yard, not because they were bad ideas, but because they were executed badly.
- cptskippy 8y agoThe comparison is completely invalid. If Apple was entering a mature market with an incumbent MP3 player that was comparable to the iPod or even better, then Apple would have had an uphill battle. They didn't. They entered a market with clearly the best device by a fair margin and people flocked to it. The Search, Social Network, and Mobile OS markets were very mature when Microsoft entered market and the products they offered weren't discernably better let alone substantially better.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoFor the record, it's because of Apple that you can say the MP3 player market was not yet mature. Regardless, my point - which might be different than your point - is first isn't always best; and that Apple's reputation as a ground-breaker can be, at times, overstated.