3 ms·
Am I the only one who is appalled that a person with a wife and for children(one under 6 months) is working in a minimum wage job? 1. They should have either n
by jelliclesfarm 8y ago
Am I the only one who is appalled that a person with a wife and for children(one under 6 months) is working in a minimum wage job?
1. They should have either not had four kids or 2. should train to pick a higher paying job. 3. Or move to a cheaper part of the country.
The question is: how do we train people for better jobs or when jobs aren’t available, how do we make sure they ..well..live?
These are the questions we should be asking and not talking about SF restaurants and housing unavailability.
Where is the ‘Linkedin’ and retraining resources for people like this cook?
This author with a MBA just didn’t make compelling reading.
- a-dub 8y agoastonishingly tone deaf. you need to get out more...
- yellowbuilding 8y agoThis is really an outrageous suggestion, when so many extremely overqualified people work in restaurants. If you have paid any attention at all, you would realize we live in an increasingly service-based economy. The repercussions of that undermine your entire thesis, which is the long-time neoliberal position that there are millions of jobs sitting empty for decades on end that could be filled if only people had gotten enough college. Well, the solutions have been pursued and all numbers conclude the diagnosis was false.
- xivzgrev 8y agoWhat is the cook going to retrain in that’s going to substantially change the picture? The only substantial wage gain would be in tech, and retraining to be a coder/designer/sales person is not a universal panacea, not everyone can do those.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI don’t know. Maybe we should create different categories of work. You are right about technical training. While people like him ought to be responsible wrt procreation and family planning...surely there has to be something from this side of job market too? Maybe restaurants WILL disappear. Like movie theatres and book stores and retail eventually will..in that case, cooking is a skill. Perhaps there has to be a program where they can cook for students or in offices with ten clients. Regulations has to be relaxed. CA food laws and business licenses are too stringent and difficult to navigate. I also want to say that in CA..being reliant on undocumented laborers in the restaurant industry has created an artificial pricing. Food is cheap but rent is high. Labour has become the unmanageable variable while in fact, food was cheap because the savings from hiring cheap labour was passed on to the customer. Or maybe the solution is going to be universal health care and universal basic income. That might be another possibility but whats happening right now isn’t sustainable.
- synaesthesisx 8y agoThe solution will be automated labor (robotic line cooks, dishwashers, etc), and labor will no longer be an unmanageable variable at this point.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoTrue. I see the same thing happening in Ag. I can tell how we will create jobs there tho’..instead of having people spraying toxic chemicals in orchards with masks on..we can have autonomous drones or sprayers but staff can be trained to use the programs and equipment. But here is the rub. Where you needed maybe 30 labourers in the field doing low wage job..now one robot and one operator/supervisor can do it for a single high paying job. So..while certainly that one person has upward mobility..what about the rest of the 29 low skill workers? How are they going to be trained and what will they do? This is something tech sector and the govt has to think about...I don’t think we have spent enough time or effort worrying about it or pursuing it...honestly..it’s not killer AI that scares me..but it’s unemployed..poor low skill people who don’t have means to support themselves in a world where jobs will get scarce is what scares me.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoI think this type of thinking is shortsighted for a few reasons, but still you have good points. It’s just very hard. In terms of children, there are many people who feel very strongly that a life goal to raise children is a moral imperative that supercedes any consideration of wealth or affordability. Many people who can only get low-skilled jobs also rely on their extended network of family, friends, church, whatever. The prospect of moving to a different place is preposterous to them, because even if they had marginally better pay compared to costs of living it would’t matter at all if they don’t have their grandmother nearby to offer frequent free child care, or they couldn’t see a longtime family friend who helps with hard times or addiction issues or many other types of things. It’s also quite hard to relocate for most people. It’s not like being a cook 5 hours away is the type of job you scout out and uproot your life over. What if that restaurant goes out of business? How much other available employment liquidity is there after you uproot & move? Who pays the relocation costs? What about uprooting kids’ lives? Finally, a lot of people have generational and/or cultural attachment to a specific place, and they believe that this also supercedes any market conditions related to housing or jobs. Doesn’t matter if it’s a natural disaster, an economic crash, or being priced out by gentrification... you have to imagine the mindset of “this is where I am from, this is where my family is,” and the feeling that if generational home can’t be sustained, that this is a greater loss than it would be to slide into poverty. Obviously not all of this applies to the situation of the article, but generally this is hard. A lot of people simply commit to an ideology they believe is literally exempt from being affected by economic conditions, and that those values transcend any other type of decision-making.
- throwawaysea 8y agoI share the same sentiment. In my opinion, having children is a huge responsibility, and should not be treated as a default right. If one cannot get themselves into a stable position financially, they shouldn't be raising children. And certainly not four. Having four children without substantial financial security is outrageously irresponsible - people I know that are very well off would hesitate to have even three despite having the technical ability to afford that life.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThat detail was rather jarring to me.
- whyenot 8y ago> working in a minimum wage job? Why is being a line cook in a relatively high-end SF restaurant a "minimum wage" job? Especially when severs in the same restaurant are apparently bringing home $80-90k a year? I don't disagree with your point, but one issue in SF and elsewhere in the Bay Area is that tech worker salaries have skyrocketed while wages for everyone else have been relatively flat. Why is that happening and what if anything can be done about it?
- cjhopman 8y agoHoly shit! Where do you live that minimum wage is $24/hr?