2 ms·
>...it goes like this...on balance AI will be good for humanity. Oh – and by the way – its progress is unstoppable ... The truly extraordinary thing, therefore,
by tim333 8y ago
>...it goes like this...on balance AI will be good for humanity. Oh – and by the way – its progress is unstoppable
... The truly extraordinary thing, therefore, is how many apparently sane people seem to take the narrative as a credible version of humanity’s future.
I don't see what's extraordinary at all. AI's coming and will probably be net good. There may be some inaccuracies in how it's reported and corporations are not all angels but for what field is that not true?
Also he says Theresa May has drunk cool aid by agreeing to fund AI but what she's funding is machine learning for cancer detection which is getting results like this
>In tests, it achieved an area under the receiver operating characteristic (AUC) — a measure of detection accuracy — of 99 percent. That’s superior to human pathologists, who according to one recent assessment miss small metastases on individual slides as much as 62 percent of the time when under time constraints. https://venturebeat.com/2018/10/12/google-ai-claims-99-accuracy-in-metastatic-breast-cancer-detection/ https://venturebeat.com/2018/10/12/google-ai-claims-99-accur...
That's for metastatic breast cancer that kills 500,000 people a year. Overall Naughton's arguments seems a bit silly.
- xg15 8y agoTo be fair though, those numbers are the results of a single evaluation of the algorithm against a single group of human experts: > In the setting of a challenge competition, some deep learning algorithms achieved better diagnostic performance than a panel of 11 pathologists participating in a simulation exercise designed to mimic routine pathology workflow; algorithm performance was comparable with an expert pathologist interpreting whole-slide images without time constraints. Whether this approach has clinical utility will require evaluation in a clinical setting. Certainly an impressive feat of image recognition, but far from revolutionising cancer diagnosis. It's also not clear to me that this would actually diagnose cancer more accurately if you factor in the ability of experts to consider other things than just the scans.
- tim333 8y agoI guess so though it seems promising. Not quite sure how it'd work in real life. I've got two friends who went to the doctor with a headache and sore throat and were told it was nothing to worry about and then a year or two later found it was cancer - one died rapidly, one presently having a bunch of surgery. It would be good if there were a better way of screening that sort of stuff.