4 ms·
>> Why do people believe so much nonsense about AI? That is the central question. Why is it that people are prepared to believe in all the wild fantasies that
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> Why do people believe so much nonsense about AI?
That is the central question. Why is it that people are prepared to believe in all the wild fantasies that the marketing arms of the tech industry come up with? Shouldn't the expectation be that the majority would instead be more cautious and avoid believing all the overblown promises, especially when they repeatedly fail to be fulfilled?
- yters 8y agoThe materialist philosophy of mainstream science and academia makes this palatable.
- matte_black 8y agoThey want to believe.
- pfortuny 8y agoToday we believe in SCIENCE (whatever that means). Hence, we believe what any of its priests says unless countered by other (more famous) priest.
- scottlegrand2 8y agoThat seems counter to the narrative that led to the current holder of the highest office in the United States, no? Because if his fans believe in unquestioningly science then why do they disbelieve in a tapas selection of the following: climate change, evolution, vaccines, gravity, a round Earth, and/or whether the moon landing happened?
- chobeat 8y agoIt's a hot topic. One very good argument I've read recently is that most of what pro-science people label as "anti-scientific" statements like anti-vax stuff are made by people that don't refuse science as a whole but just science coming from what they perceive is a corrupted establishment. Clearly this involve cherry-picking that validates their ideological positions, or it's just following the twisted narrative of some political group. Science, with the capital S, is still society's reference framework for truth (and this is a huge problem, but not the one we are talking about) but these people refute the priests and the religion, not the God. New priests are bending the same God to their interests and the times favor them over the previous priests.
- c1ccccc1 8y agoSpeak for yourself. I personally prefer to evaluate the statements of scientists on a claim by claim basis.
- mwfunk 8y agoI wish I could say that people believed in science. Priests (literal ones, not metaphorical ones like your strawmen) seem to have more influence over public policy in much of the world though, including America, and more often than not to the detriment of all.
- noobiemcfoob 8y agoThe benefit about being more honest about their role in society: they get to exploit it more thoroughly.
- dmreedy 8y agoAgreed. My pet theory is that it boils down to how superficially accessible AI is. A conversation about AI is kind of like Bikeshedding, except no one realizes it's actually a conversation about the Nuclear Power Plant. Everyone's got practical, direct experience with sentience, with thinking, with speaking a language, with seeing things. Everyone can introspect for a little bit and make genuine claims to having contemplated the fundamental problems of AI. And since so little genuine progress on the really fundamental parts of the problem (the Hard Problem, as Chalmers would say, versus the somewhat more tractable 'parsing problems' that Deep Learning has made such great gains on), the most frustrating part is that it's really hard to prove some amateur thinker's conclusions wrong. You can bury them with the technical jargon of three thousand years of philosophers, but no one's been able to build a formally verifiable model for the whole thing so far, and so amateurs and experts are in some sense separated only by how impressively technical they sound when talking about the matter. This problem is amplified by the technical jargon being painfully close to the technical jargon for philosophy of the mind, and to straight lay terminology. So a person with technical knowledge can talk about, say, 'training', and a person with no technical knowledge can think they understand, because the word is so ill-separated from their own internal, non-technical definition. It's so easy to have an opinion about AI, the fundamental ideas are so prevalent in day-to-day discourse, and it's so hard to prove any given opinion wrong.
- Barrin92 8y ago>Why is it that people are prepared to believe in all the wild fantasies that the marketing arms of the tech industry come up with? Because very influential people have thrown their weight into the discussion I would say. You have Kurzweil who basically predicts that the singularity is imminent every five years, and you had Musk and Hawking painting apocalyptic scenarios about AI. That dominated the AI pop news headlines for weeks if not months. On the other hand people like Andrew Ng or Kai-Fu Lee who actually work in the industry and draw attention to the socio-economic impact of AI, which is very real, seem to only find an audience within the community itself, if at all. The reason is probably twofold. Terminator-esque stories are more interesting than talking about the economic impact of AI, and the industry has a lot more to gain by distracting people with grandiose scenarios than by talking about the negative impact they have on the lives of working people and society at large.
- tim333 8y ago>You have Kurzweil who basically predicts that the singularity is imminent every five years Kurzweil has always predicted the singularity for 2045. He may be wrong but I don't find that prediction or Musk and Hawking say AI may be dangerous as wild fantasies. You can make reasoned arguments for all that stuff.