3 ms·
Interesting, but there seem to be a lot of assumptions baked into the default "used car market" example, that don't necessarily hold up. For example, the idea t
by mindcrime 8y ago
Interesting, but there seem to be a lot of assumptions baked into the default "used car market" example, that don't necessarily hold up. For example, the idea that the owner knows whether they hold a "peach" or a "lemon". Clearly he/she has some idea, but they definitely do not have perfect knowledge of this. In fact, this very lack of knowledge ("how many more miles will I get out of this car before the transmission falls out?") may be the reason the owner has chosen to manage risk by buying a newer car. But the actual answer to that question could be anywhere from "1 more mile" to "another 250,000+ miles".
Likewise, this statement:
Given the fixed price at which buyers will buy, sellers will sell only when they hold "lemons" (since plemon < pavg) and they will leave the market when they hold "peaches"
is iffy. As the owner of a used car, I may choose to buy a newer car for any number of reasons, including just wanting something to impress my peers, or impress members of the opposite sex, whatever. Say I buy a nice, sexy, new sports-car. I don't need my old car anymore, regardless of whether it is a peach or a lemon. But my decision to sell it may not involve its status as "peach" or "lemon". It may simply be that I don't want to pay property taxes and registration fees on a car I'm not using. Maybe I just don't have anywhere to park a second car. Or maybe I'm just feeling generous and want to help somebody else out by selling them my no-longer-needed car.
All of that said, I'm sure the math is valid and this theory has uses... but this used car thing feels a little dodgy.
- danieltillett 8y agoA lemon is not a car that is about to have major problems, but one that has had many problems in the past. The current owner knows if they have a lemon or not. Knowing if you have a peach or not is more complex, but as the owner of a 10 year old car that has had nothing go wrong with it, I a reluctant to sell it despite being able to afford a much newer car - why take the risk of getting a lemon when I can just keep driving my current car.
- mindcrime 8y agoA lemon is not a car that is about to have major problems, but one that has had many problems in the past. The current owner knows if they have a lemon or not. Sure, to some extent. Anyway, all I'm saying is that this example is less clear-cut than the authors make it out to be. Just to drill into this a little more: say a person has a 10 year old car, that has needed a timing belt and a water pump in the last year (but no major problems before that). Is that a lemon? Arguably. Or it could just be a 10 year old car that's needed two of the common repairs required of cars as they age. Is it going to need more major repairs soon? Hard to say. It could be that the low-hanging fruit have been picked off now, and that it's going to be fine for several more years. Knowing if you have a peach or not is more complex, but as the owner of a 10 year old car that has had nothing go wrong with it, I a reluctant to sell it despite being able to afford a much newer car - why take the risk of getting a lemon when I can just keep driving my current car. Sure, but if everybody thought that way, nobody with a functioning car would ever upgrade to a new car. And we know from observation that that is not the case. People buy new cars for all sorts of reasons, and quite often they sell their old car as a consequence. This also ignores the fact that there are signals a buyer can use that correlate to the quality of the used car, even if they aren't perfect indicators. Mileage and year, for example. And price discrimination based on these factors obviously takes place. It seems clear that there is a market for used cars across a varying continuum of "goodness".
- sokoloff 8y agoThe concept of information asymmetry doesn't apply at all to year of car (buyer and seller agree on that fact based on title and VIN) and largely doesn't apply to mileage (barring odometer rollback known only to seller or "total mileage unknown" brand on the title which is relatively uncommon).
- mindcrime 8y agoThe concept of information asymmetry doesn't apply at all to year of car (buyer and seller agree on that fact based on title and VIN) and largely doesn't apply to mileage That's exactly my point. The apparent information asymmetry regarding the overall "goodness" of the used car, is mediated by the presence of strong signals about that goodness, which are available to all parties. Note that I'm not saying they eliminate the overall asymmetry, just that they reduce it.
- zwaps 8y agoIt's a model. A pretty good one, since the mechanism at play here can occur in a very general sense. The car market is an example where this effect may occur, as is insurance and finance. However, in reality, there are many more things going on that this model abstracts from. Nevertheless, the basic issue of asymmetric information shown in this model exists, to some degree, among other effects. You should not understand this paper as a statement about the used car market. So for example: You say the owner does not know whether it is a lemon or peach. Well, the model is about asymmetry. Everything goes through if the owner (on average) knows MORE than the buyer. I think that's pretty fair, and if it is not the case, we are not dealing with an information asymmetry and the model is silent on the matter. Similarly, clearly cars are not just two types, lemon and peach. But again, results will hold if you make introduce more and more classes. It just makes the math less simple. You also say that some people do not sell their car because it is a lemon. True. But again, on average, the rate of lemons for a given price will be higher than it would be if you could identify the quality of a car exactly - because it is sufficient that some people sell their lemons as peaches. You could introduce all this in the model, you just probably wouldn't learn anything new. It's a good model, because its simple and even if you throw more stuff at it, the mechanism persists to a degree. Clearly, in reality, more things are going on than just this. But reading the paper we learn about an issue that exists within the complex system, and that is valuable.
- mindcrime 8y agoBut reading the paper we learn about an issue that exists within the complex system, and that is valuable. Agreed, that why I said "All of that said, I'm sure the math is valid and this theory has uses." My criticism (if you want to call it that) isn't of the fundamental, underlying theory... it's more with the specific example chose to illustrate it. I suspect that there is a better example model they could have chosen.
- nabla9 8y agoThe example is used for illustrative purposes.
- ucaetano 8y agoThe model isn't about cars, used or otherwise.
- londons_explore 8y agoImagine there were two places to sell used cars. For example a dealer, where buyers could take it for a test drive, and auction, where you see it and have to bid on sight alone. In such a situation, the lemons would gravitate to the auctionhouse, while the peaches end up at dealers.