4 ms·
Having no idea what you have heard, I can only comment on the original post. Perhaps if I have had the same input as you did, maybe we would be in agreement. ‘
by jelliclesfarm 8y ago
Having no idea what you have heard, I can only comment on the original post. Perhaps if I have had the same input as you did, maybe we would be in agreement.
‘Venting’ to public at large should still be taken with a pinch of salt (and disdain) especially since it’s done anonymously.
Again. Your personal circle of friends who happen to be teachers is not the same sample as the posters quoted in the original post.
And I can say this for every single point you make about ‘teachers you know’ and I will still hold my opinion that the first word that came to my mind when I read the original post is ‘toxic’.
Having said that..wrt your circle of teacher acquaintances and my own impressions, I think education as we know it needs to undergo a sea change.
Perhaps this notion of cramming 30-50 children in a room and force feeding them ‘education’ via a low paid, unhappy teacher is not a way to transmit knowledge or a love for learning.
I think if someone has a ‘calling’, they should do it for free or must be free to walk away without worrying about their means to survive. Since it’s a career choice, it carries with it all the baggage of a rat race. One can’t have it both ways.
Considering these very teachers are products of the same system of education, they are merely perpetuating the unpleasantness that they had to endure.
I see this as abuse on many levels. Education and schools as we know it must die and take up another avatar.
Parents and administrators (at least here in California) have little to no power. It’s a battle for public money between unions and Sacramento. That’s what I see from what I have observed. It’s really very dirty politics. Teachers have chosen a side and it seems like they’d say anything they are instructed to opine. For example: there is a ‘work to rule’. It’s like a walk out. Teachers will only work for 5.5 hours teaching. They won’t grade papers, won’t write recommendation letters, won’t communicate with teachers. This happened six months ago too. 25000 teachers in LAUSD are striking in Los Angeles Unified schools. No classes. Nothing. Full on strike. This isn’t a calling. When one joins an union and goes on strike, it’s not a “calling”.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this, but I am not sure it has made a difference. I have heard others say the same thing second hand but the first hand opinions that I have heard from teachers themselves have been different.
- rland 8y agoI have heard the exact opposite. That teachers increasingly have to acquiesce to the demands of parents and administrators. That they want to be creative and exercise their "calling," the art of it and care given to individual students. But they cannot because they're pressured by onerous top-down regulation, school administration, or blowback from zealous parents. And also, yeah I wish everyone could perform their calling for free, for the simple joy of it, but the fact of the matter is that life isn't like that and never will be like that.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoInteresting. Who has a say in a child’s education? Let’s go over the parties involved: 1. Parents 2. Teachers 3. Administrators 4. Union 5. The State 6. Tax payers/public 7. The Student It would be interesting to map the relationships between these various players and their influence weights.
- ColinWright 8y agoDrive-by reply for the sake of completeness and some clarification ... > Perhaps if I have had the same input as you did, maybe we would be in agreement. Perhaps - given my context (see below) it seems likely I've had and have much more contact with teachers than you, and so have more insight into what it's like to be a teacher. > Your personal circle of friends who happen to be teachers is not the same sample as the posters quoted in the original post. I'm not referring to my circle of friends. I have extensive professional contact with hundreds of teachers every year (in the UK). > ... education as we know it needs to undergo a sea change. This is true, and I'm working with some to try to make it happen. But it's Sisyphean. > I think if someone has a ‘calling’, they should do it for free or must be free to walk away without worrying about their means to survive. Since it’s a career choice, it carries with it all the baggage of a rat race. One can’t have it both ways. People go into the career with the clear-eyed innocence of youth, and as the years go by get ground into the ground by the administrative load and the toxicity of the parents and community. But teaching is important, and many/most soldier on, trying to teach the students regardless of the circumstances. In the vast majority of cases the teachers really are doing absolutely everything they can to give the students the best education possible under the circumstances. In short, I disagree with you on this. > When one joins an union and goes on strike, it’s not a “calling”. I disagree completely. When one despairs of making any progress, and of being able to do what the students need, going on strike can be the best thing for the students as a whole. Without doubt it is damaging to the current students in the short term, but you are saying the system needs to change. How can it change without those at the coal face taking some action? > Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this, but I am not sure it has made a difference. I have heard others say the same thing second hand but the first hand opinions that I have heard from teachers themselves have been different. I have no doubt that you are concerned for the right things, and I have no doubt that we agree on much. There may be things we disagree on, but I suspect it's for the right reasons, and because there are no simple answers or quick fixes. Education must change radically, and it's unclear that it can happen without significant disruption. I have concerns for those who will be caught in the mess. Above all, I desperately wish the students got a better deal than they currently get, and I equally desperately wish the system would get out of the way of the good teachers and let them teach. It has to change, but I don't know how.