2 ms·
A couple of historical clarifications to Sedgewick Wayne's points: > [SICP] set the curriculum for "beginning" computer science > All [examples and exercises]
by gumby 8y ago
A couple of historical clarifications to Sedgewick Wayne's points:
> [SICP] set the curriculum for "beginning" computer science
> All [examples and exercises] use complex domain knowledge. ... Some early sections and the last two chapters cover topics from computer science ...
Why the square quotes around "beginning"? At the time the course, 6.001, was launched it was quite reasonable to assume that an MIT undergrad might arrive at the Institute never having previously used a computer, much less programmed one. This was truly an introductory class and while required for all EE and CS students, was intended for any undergraduate. The material in the examples all covered core subjects every student needs in oder to graduate, or else were computer science topics that should hardly shock someone taking a computer science class.
Some of the other criticism is reasonable in light of the authors' desire for a slightly different approach. 6.001 was and is the basic introductory class and a CS student will take other classes which will address different aspects of program design and application. Choosing a different time of introduction for different objectives is hardly unreasonable.
(And I don't know why object-oriented programming is somehow thought to be in opposition to the principles of SCIP; the latter's heart is abstraction and composition which are the whole point of object-oriented thinking, right?)
- svat 8y agoAll very interesting, but what do Sedgewick and Wayne have to do with any of this? Your first quote is from the post's author (Steven Rosenberg says the site header), and the second quote is from the authors of How To Design Programs (Felleisen, Findler, Flatt, Krishnamurthi).
- gumby 8y agoThanks for catching that. Unfortunately it’s too late for me to edit my misattributions.