6 ms·
It's a bit of a shame that there isn't a company that offers corporate IRC hosting with a client as rich as the Slack client.
by dehrmann 8y ago
It's a bit of a shame that there isn't a company that offers corporate IRC hosting with a client as rich as the Slack client.
- Aloha 8y agoYou'd have to extend IRC so much, that it would cease to be IRC.
- matte_black 8y agoIs that a problem?
- Aloha 8y agoWhy not develop a new protocol, and not try to call it IRC - there are many things about IRC that suck, specifically its support for push messaging and mobile.
- paulryanrogers 8y agoXMPP and Matrix are at least two
- donatj 8y agoI don't think it needs to be. Just have the rich content be a URL and the rich client will know what to do with it, and humans using other clients can follow the link. We actual do this with an IRC client we developed for internal use.
- rocky1138 8y agoI know it doesn't directly answer your problem, but running thelounge on a node server can do a pretty good job. It supports user-based logins and since it's running as a service, chat history is supported. Currently there's no way to search, but I imagine that could be implemented in the future. https://thelounge.chat/ https://thelounge.chat/
- xPaw 8y agov3.0 adds message storage with sqlite, and message search will be built on top of that (there's a proof of concept pull request open with it).
- lscotte 8y agoThe thing is, all you need is what IRC offers. All I need, anyway. Just plain ASCII is perfect - I don't need or want emoticons or any of the other bloat. Just plain text is so nice.
- loeg 8y agoThe world is bigger than just USA. Plain UTF-8 is just fine, though, and IRC supports it.
- crowbahr 8y agoProblem is that most people want to have reactions, replies in chains etc. I personally quite like IRC but I understand why people are less keen. It's not the way of the majority. Probably not the way of the entire center of the bell curve.
- loeg 8y agoI doubt most people care about reactions. Replies in chains are a mixed bag. It makes it easier to follow that particular conversation, but the UI/UX is godawful to the point of it being more confusing than just in-band discussion, IMO.
- dingaling 8y agoReactions are useful because they provide acknowledgement without clutter or notification. For example in Whatsapp I often check a notification and find its just a smiley or thumbs-up
- pavel_lishin 8y agoWhat about threads? Mentions? Mentions across channels? Client-independent history? Search? File attachments? Interactive features like polls? I'm glad that IRC works for you, but it's 2018. We can do better than slate and chalk.
- mavhc 8y ago
- gkoberger 8y agoWell, originally there was a IRC gateway for Slack. But at the end of the day, it just lessens the experience for everyone. I'm all for open protocols in theory, however I'm yet to see it go well since it only works if every platform implements every feature in almost the same way... and at that point, you might as well just use the same client. Some of the benefits of Slack are things like: - the rich integrations - emoji responses + emoji statuses - video calls that "just work" - good search (for stored knowledge across a company) - pinned messages - notifications people are snoozed and the ability to force a notification (That being said, https://grove.io https://grove.io attempts to do this!)
- loeg 8y ago> But at the end of the day, it just lessens the experience for everyone. Pff, speak for yourself. I used the slack IRC gateway until it was shut down as an alternative to just not using slack. Now I use wee-slack, which works great. To respond point by point: - the rich integrations [don't know what you mean] - emoji responses + emoji statuses [wee-slack has this] - video calls that "just work" [didn't know Slack had this] - good search (for stored knowledge across a company) [Slack doesn't have this] - pinned messages [not sure what this is good for; are you familiar with IRC's "/topic"?] - notifications people are snoozed and the ability to force a notification [IRC's had the former in many forms for years and I don't think the latter is a benefit]
- overtmind 8y agoWhat do you do when people call you?
- RHSeeger 8y ago- good search (for stored knowledge across a company) Slack's search is absolutely horrible, in my opinion. It's one of the things I complain about.
- dewey 8y agoWhat about https://www.irccloud.com https://www.irccloud.com?
- dmitriid 8y agoIronically, IRCCloud does everything what Slack is hated for: inline images and gifs, electron/browser-based client, closed source, paid subscriptions...
- pseudalopex 8y agoIRCCloud doesn't prevent someone from using another client.
- dewey 8y agoI think the main points of criticism about Slack are not the ones you listed. It's that it's a proprietary protocol, a data silo that can't easily be accessed, the bait and switch of first supporting IRC and then killing off the gateway, forced to use the official electron/browser based client. I never heart anyone complain about inline images / gifs (which is also something that most IRC clients support) or that it's paid (which IRC bouncers / clients are often too in cases).
- Thaxll 8y agoBecause IRC is old and badly designed. People keep talking about IRC but no one want to go back there because it's just bad compare to Slack, there is no history, no rich text, no integration what's so ever to anything recent.
- darkpuma 8y ago> People keep talking about IRC but no one want to go back there Speak for yourself. I never left and I find it very tedious when I'm forced to use anything else. In practice 90% of the justification for any other system seems to be that people want to post inane cat pictures at each other. That just isn't worth the tradeoffs for me. The 'modern replacements' for IRC are even bigger workplace distractions than IRC.
- overtmind 8y agoOh come on can we drop the cat pictures trope? I use RocketChat for my consulting business for a few reasons that are largely unavailable on IRC without bots: 1) Rich text and syntax highlighting - Small properly fenced off code blocks are a wonder. Contrast that to IRC where it would never look quite right, relies on the other person's client to have monospaced fonts, and usually gets you yelled at for flooding 2) URL expanding - Viewing titles and a snippet of the content is useful. Requires bots on IRC. 3) File sharing in a trivial non-p2p. Nobody liked DCC, and I shudder thinking of going back to opening port ranges for that. 4) Reliability of having a central history which alleviates needing a bouncer, and reduces how important a stable connection actually is. The only other thing you could come back with is to use yet other external platforms to alleviate those issues like: For 1) An external public/private pastebin solution For 2) A bot as I already said For 3) An external filsharing service: Dropbox, Nextcloud, etc For 4) External bnc: ZNC, bip, weechat, irssi etc RocketChat, Mattermost, Slack, et al incorporate all of those things and more and are inherently useful - Plus, if you're the administrator you don't have to enable gifs or cat pictures, yes that shit is dumb.
- darkpuma 8y agoIRC bots are trivial to implement and run so I don't consider many of these, which are commonly provided by IRC bots, as legitimate arguments against IRC. I don't consider "but you need a bot" to be a legitimate gripe. Rich text is generally worthless except for code highlighting, but pasting large amounts of code into the channel is generally considered antisocial on IRC anyway, and pastebin services are used for this. It's not unusual for a company to provide their own internal pastebin services anyway, since it's generally useful with other systems like email. Ditto file sharing. > "Oh come on can we drop the cat pictures trope?" No, because in my personal experience that is OVERWHELMINGLY the most frequently used feature of slack/etc that's not present in IRC. For every time I've seen pasted code, I've seen easily a hundred inane pasted memes. I wouldn't bring it up if I didn't earnestly believe it's the primary reason people prefer systems other than IRC.
- jonty 8y agoThat is exactly what IRCCloud does.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoHow would this be different than Slack?
- EduardoBautista 8y agoBecause it would be using IRC, an open protocol.
- purerandomness 8y agoYou could connect to it through a terminal client and save gigabytes of RAM.
- Jaruzel 8y agoMy problem with Slack (and all the Slack clones) is that they all look the same, and have a style that wastes so much screen space. I like to have a small chat window sitting in the corner of my screen that I can glance at and keep track of without having to interrupt my current workflow . IRC clients were great for this; Nice and compact which just the conversation at the fore. So yes, give me UTF-8, Emojis, Reactions, Inline Replies, but all in a more compact UI please.