4 ms·
I just don't buy the Carbon Fiber vs Stainless construction. They aren't used for the same thing (low weight structural stiffness vs heat conduction, radiation
by kurthr 8y ago
I just don't buy the Carbon Fiber vs Stainless construction. They aren't used for the same thing (low weight structural stiffness vs heat conduction, radiation & appearance).
From what I understand it was a water tank contactor that did the hopper in Boca Chica... and it will never face lanch/re-entry stresses. That won't replace anyone.
- theptip 8y ago> They aren't used for the same thing The old BFR design had a large carbon-fiber hull, the new one has a stainless steel hull. Unless I'm missing your point, that's a major piece of the rocket that's no longer made with carbon fiber. (The giant molds that they were building for the BFR hull, for example, are now redundant.)
- kurthr 8y agoIt's not for production, it's for testing and looking cool.
- caconym_ 8y agoFrom what I understand, the plan is for the production Starship to have a stainless steel skin. I'm sure it will be a much more refined construction than the hopper, but skinned in stainless steel nonetheless. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BFR_(rocket)#Second_stage_and_spaceship:_Starship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BFR_(rocket)#Second_stage_and_...
- theptip 8y agoWat. Sources please to back up this wild assertion? The stainless steel hull is a viable design (though obviously given how many times it has changed it might not be final). Scott Manley did a deep dive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVgEKBwE2RM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVgEKBwE2RM
- solotronics 8y agoHow will they inspect and test all the welds required... I am still shocked that the BFR is not carbon fiber.
- kurthr 8y agoIt's just a hopper to test new methanol engines... it will never see flight.
- HeadsUpHigh 8y agoHow do you inspect small creaks in a cf build? If I had to guess inspecting welds is probably easier.
- HeadsUpHigh 8y agoThe starhopper( test article) is indeed made by a water tank contactor. The actual starship will be made by stainless steel in LA as confirmed by Musk on twitter. Also he mentioned something about stainless steel having better properties than cf.