3 ms·
I grew up bothered by this on many levels. Not only some of us feel negatively for the struggle. I believe that ~learning the results teaches less than learning
by agumonkey 8y ago
I grew up bothered by this on many levels. Not only some of us feel negatively for the struggle. I believe that ~learning the results teaches less than learning how to solve it. I does accelerate learning and allow people not to reinvent all 4 wheels... but reading old papers (there's a video on Newton's very own notebook, it is so damn different from anything I've ever read about physics) tickles another part of your mind.
- codetrotter 8y ago> there's a video on Newton's very own notebook, it is so damn different from anything I've ever read about physics Sounds interesting. Would like to watch it. Got a link?
- agumonkey 8y agoI think that's this one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ObPg3ki9GOI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ObPg3ki9GOI They don't review all of it, but you can get a few pages read
- vanderZwan 8y agoSimilarly, a lot of James Clerk Maxwell's writing can be found on Archive.org, and it's amazing: https://archive.org/search.php?query=maxwell%2C+james+clerk&and%5B%5D=creator%3A%22james+clerk+maxwell%22&and%5B%5D=creator%3A%22maxwell%2C+james+clerk%2C+1831-1879%22&sort=-date&page=2 https://archive.org/search.php?query=maxwell%2C+james+clerk&...
- agumonkey 8y agotoo easy, last night I went to Gilbert De Magnete (original in latin no less) http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/33810?msg=welcome_stranger http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/33810?msg=welcome_stranger
- vanderZwan 8y agoYou joke (and cool find), but Maxwell's writings one the subject of electromagnetism are indeed a lot easier to grasp than some modern textbooks
- agumonkey 8y agoI don't doubt it
- PaulHoule 8y agoIt's not unusual that original scientific works are more clear than the later works of people trying to explain them. The original author has to persuade people, and convince people who aren't familiar with them. The "pedagogical" author later is in a more clear position of authority and doesn't need to work as hard.
- wolfgke 8y ago> The original author has to persuade people, and convince people who aren't familiar with them. The "pedagogical" author later is in a more clear position of authority and doesn't need to work as hard. Or perhaps: The "pedagogical" author can assume that by the time of his writing, we live in a society where it is accepted that there is nothing mysterious about the material (e.g. imaginary numbers are nothing mysterious) and can concentrate on explaining the material in the best possible way. The problem is that many students come from a background where they were taught a deeply anti-scientific attitude. EDIT: To put it more concisely: It is a different job to convince someone of a scientific result (here the other side is distrusting) than to teach it (here the other side gives you credit of trust (but a lack of understanding) and you have to teach them so that they understand it). Unluckily many students who attend lectures have an attitude where they need to be convinced instead of taught.
- chibg10 8y ago>Unluckily many students who attend lectures have an attitude where they need to be convinced instead of taught. Isn't this backwards? If you're just accepting the lecturer's word as dogma, I would argue you're not really gaining an education at all. The process of being convinced and having doubts about the material resolved improves critical thinking and improves understanding of the underlying material as well.
- newen 8y agoThat's how you become the annoying student in the algorithms class who interrupts the professor all the time and ruins the class.