3 ms·
Rooftop solar doesn't use any additional land and the US has vast tracks of mostly uninhabited deserts. I would be very interested in a comparison between sola
by adrianN 8y ago
Rooftop solar doesn't use any additional land and the US has vast tracks of mostly uninhabited deserts.
I would be very interested in a comparison between solar and nuclear regarding their manufacturing. It's not like nuclear fuel pellets grow on trees either. Do you have any sources perhaps?
- killjoywashere 8y agoThe bulk of the Manhattan Project's $33B budget went into uranium and plutonium production. The K-25 plant at Oak Ridge gives you a sense of the scale: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan_Project#/media/File:K-25_aerial_view.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan_Project#/media/File:...
- mimixco 8y agoHelen Caldicott's book (linked above) has quite a bit about this. One aspect of nuclear that's never brought up is that the mining process is carbon-intensive (all gas powered machines) and very dirty. It pollutes the surrounding environment terribly. The entire process of producing uranium pellets is really toxic and unsafe. Another aspect that's never counted in the costs of nuclear power is decommissioning. This gets passed onto the consumer in the form of rate hikes -- after the plant has been turned off! There has never been a real assessment of the costs of nuclear power that includes all these factors.
- ekianjo 8y ago> One aspect of nuclear that's never brought up is that the mining process is carbon-intensive (all gas powered machines) So is the process of making solar panels: there's so solar powered machine manufacturing the solar panels after all! However I would wage the ratio of carbon consumption over the lifetime of a nuclear plant is extremely favorable compared to the lifetime energy output. > in the costs of nuclear power is decommissioning How about the costs of recycling/destruction of solar panels? They don't last forever (far from that) and you also need to take in account that the cost of solar panels (already heavily subsidized in many countries) does not include that kind of things either. As for decommissioning nuclear plants, it's not "unknown" in any way, there are already multiple cases in the US and in Europe where plants have been stopped and decommissioned and the economic impact can be estimated and calculated.
- ekianjo 8y ago> Rooftop solar doesn't use any additional land and the US has vast tracks of mostly uninhabited deserts. The problem of putting solar panels in deserts is well known: it's not where people live, so you need a way to transport the electricity, and you lose a lot of energy between where it is produced and where it is consumed. So, putting them in deserts is a terrible idea. On rooftops it makes a lot more sense in regions that get good sunlight.