9 ms·
Only Nuclear Energy Can Save the Planet
- Graham67 8y agoThere are 3 possibilities: we go extinct we lose civilisation, we do just fine. Science does not us 30 years, it gives us 12, nowhere near enough to build nukes. With the loss of coordinated civilisation, whatever spent fuel pools, will dry up and catch fire. Spent fuel needs 3 decades onsite before it can be moved anyway. So to prevent all the SFP's putting their toxic load into the atmosphere, and killing everything bigger than bacteria, we need to decide to take an alternative to the scorched earth policy.
- calciphus 8y agoTo clarify - your argument against nuclear energy is that the world is going to collapse in 12 years;therefore something with a 30 year investment and maintenance cliff is foolish? Because it may start post-apocalyptic wasteland fires? Also what are SFPs?
- auct 8y agoI remember one dude wanted to cover moon with solar systems and then take that energy to earth with some laser or smth. He said it will require 1trln dollars but it will cover all people energy needs. I suppose nobody wanted to risk such money and people with oil business didn't want it to succeed. Now I think we should diversify and make more nuclear power plant. Also while it's building think about more ways to make energy. I dunno why scientists didn't figure out great way to make energy.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- secfirstmd 8y agoI visited Chernobyl last month. Nuclear energy is not the future.
- adrianN 8y agoChernobyl is not representative.
- mimixco 8y agoIt's one of three major meltdowns that left a permanently "scorched earth," as another poster called it. There have been many more which were not so well known. In fact, every nuclear plant around the world has had leaks and safety problems. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_nuclear_disasters_and_radioactive_incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lists_of_nuclear_disasters_and...
- pl-94 8y agoGood point. Do you know many people died in Chernobyl? 31 during the accident. 11 since (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_disaster https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_disaster). Do you know many people died every year with fine particles? 2.1 millions. Nuclear is even competitive with solar panels in terms of death. (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents) Death is of course not the real measure. But it gives you a real insight of the dangerousness.
- rozhok 8y ago>11 since You're wrong. You'd better to reference to following articles: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_disaster https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_the_Chernobyl_disaster#Long-term_health_effects https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_the_Chernobyl_dis...
- lowry 8y agoThe maximum universally accepted death tall is 4000 but it is not actual deaths but rather outcome of statistical simulations. Still, much lower than 2.1 mln.
- 8y ago
- nicodjimenez 8y agoDon’t sleep on space solar power.
- umanwizard 8y agoIt seems unlikely that we’ll invent that before it’s too late. Nuclear is feasible today.
- nicodjimenez 8y agoSure, bet against human ingenuity, that's a good bet!
- adrianN 8y agoBuilding nuclear reactors takes a long time. At this point it's probably too late to start without pursuing many different strategies to reduce our carbon output. I don't think we have enough time left for a painless transition to carbon neutrality. If we had started in earnest when it was first clear that global heating is happening, so forty years ago, we would have been able to switch to alternative power sources with a lot less economic impact. But by now only radical changes to our way of life can limit (not prevent!) global heating. The longer we wait, the larger the risk that we hit some nonlinearities that our climate models have failed to take into account.
- bluthru 8y agoIn the US it takes about 14 years for a new fission plant. You can make a lot of PV panels, wind turbines, and storage in that amount of time. You will also get economies of scale benefits and technology improvements.
- ekianjo 8y agoYou should compare all aspects. How much land it uses, how much energy it produces over 50 years, how dirty is the manufacturing process (solar panels involve extremely toxic materials to be made) etc... Its not black and white.
- adrianN 8y agoRooftop solar doesn't use any additional land and the US has vast tracks of mostly uninhabited deserts. I would be very interested in a comparison between solar and nuclear regarding their manufacturing. It's not like nuclear fuel pellets grow on trees either. Do you have any sources perhaps?
- killjoywashere 8y agoThe bulk of the Manhattan Project's $33B budget went into uranium and plutonium production. The K-25 plant at Oak Ridge gives you a sense of the scale: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan_Project#/media/File:K-25_aerial_view.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan_Project#/media/File:...
- 33a 8y agoSpeaking as someone who lives off grid: solar technology today is more than good enough to solve this problem, but people will have to adjust their lifestyle to consume less energy. Switching to a finite off grid battery bank it's remarkable how quickly you adapt to just doing less energy intensive stuff.
- monochromatic 8y agoIt’s more than good enough to solve the problem, as long as you redefine the problem sufficiently?
- adrianN 8y agoThe problem is becoming carbon neutral without turning the clock back to before we discovered coal.
- killjoywashere 8y agohow do you cook?
- bluthru 8y agoWhat were your biggest lifestyle changes?
- AmericanChopper 8y agoPersonal solar installations are the least efficient and least reliable form of renewable energy. It’s great for people like you who are really motivated to do it, but telling people to demand less energy is not a solution to the worlds energy demands. I highly question how responsible it is to promote such a patently unviable solution as being a realistic way to meet global energy demands.
- hakfoo 8y agoIt does have two appeals though: 1. Decentralized generation may be good for the network. Even if we have large utility-owned solar plants, it would be better if you can put a few hundred square metres in each neighbourhood, rather than 500 square kilometres together in the middle of nowhere. Reduced waste of energy from transmission-wire resistance, and less load on old/fragile parts of the grid if most of the current is being drawn from a nearby solar farm. 2. A way for consumers to hedge on electricity prices. From a financial perspective, there's not a big difference between "You get this 20-year lease/financing for a 5kW solar setup for $80 per month" and "You're contracting for 900 kilowatthours per month for the next 20 years, at a fixed rate of about 9 cents per kilowatthour, regardless of inflation or rate hikes."
- natch 8y agoSolutions that concentrate control in the hands of a centralized authority? No thanks. I prefer solar, which is still highly underutilized and way easier to keep independent of central control. And wind, and hydro. And I just take the headline to mean that somebody at the WSJ stands to profit from a (unlikely) nuclear power resurgence. BTW for anyone who brings up the problem of the sun not shining at night, that is a solved problem, with the ongoing advances in and availability of battery technology.
- bluthru 8y agoThis is a good point. Local energy co-ops can create their own solar farms.
- Meekro 8y agoBill Gates gave an interesting TED talk on this subject[1]. He said that in terms of the real politics, the only way to move to 100% renewable energy is to make it cheaper than fossil fuels so the naysayers have no reason to object. To that end, he has been investing heavily in TerraPower, a company developing a new kind of nuclear reactor that promises to be much safer and use the depleted uranium from other power plants as fuel. Unfortunately, TerraPower recently received a major setback. It took them 10 years to secure a deal with the Chinese government to build one of their prototype power plants there, and now the Trump administration's aggressive stance toward China has killed that deal. Hopefully they'll be able to find another arrangement before they run out of funding. [1] https://www.ted.com/talks/bill_gates?language=en#t-814991 https://www.ted.com/talks/bill_gates?language=en#t-814991
- acqq 8y agohttps://www.technologyreview.com/s/542686/terrapower-quietly-explores-new-nuclear-reactor-strategy/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/542686/terrapower-quietly... „six years after it was founded, TerraPower has not yet produced a working prototype. Last week, at Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee, the company revealed that it is now pursuing a different advanced reactor concept: a molten chloride reactor“ That was 2016. Any improvements since?
- pl-94 8y agoA good benchmark for nuclear vs wind turbine is France (2nd country with the most installed nuclear power) and Danemark (Can run almost entirely on wind turbines). Well, France is producing about a factor of 2 or 3 less CO2 than Danemark. Another important point. France is producing still far too much CO2 because nuclear is just about 20% of its energy consumption. So let's not focus on electricity, but let's stop using fuel for transportation and gas for heating.
- gralx 8y agoPersonal transportation is one thing, but the figures for overseas shipping, airplane exhaust, and animal farming constitute well over 30% of total GHG emissions. It's scary. Nevertheless, eliminating fossil fuels in personal transportation (about 13%) is a necessary step. Another benchmark: Canada's largest province, Ontario, gets 60% of its electricity from nuclear. It has more than twice the population of Denmark, and one-fifth that of France. EDIT: I misunderstood. I see now you were comparing a nuclear-dominant country with a wind-dominant one.
- pl-94 8y agoAirplane is just 2% of world CO2 emissions. It makes sense of course to reduce it, but at the world scale, farming and coal are the real burden!
- carboy 8y agoThe only thing that can save most of humanity is a method that can scrub 100M metric tons of green houses gases from the upper atmosphere on a yearly basis. If the earth’s climate were a person it would be 5ft tall, weigh 600lbs and eat 15,000 calories a day, and the plan to save it would be to have it reduce its food intake to 12,000 calories a day. We are not fixing anything, the earth’s climate would just get fatter a little slower.
- ForHackernews 8y agohttps://www.vox.com/2016/10/4/13118594/2-degrees-no-more-fossil-fuels https://www.vox.com/2016/10/4/13118594/2-degrees-no-more-fos... "This image should terrify you. It should be on billboards. As you can see, in either scenario, global emissions must peak and begin declining immediately. For a medium chance to avoid 1.5 degrees, the world has to zero out net carbon emissions by 2050 or so — for a good chance of avoiding 2 degrees, by around 2065. After that, emissions have to go negative. Humanity has to start burying a lot more carbon than it throws up into the atmosphere. ... Thus far, most demonstration plants of any size attaching [carbon capture] to fossil fuel facilities have been over-budget disasters. What if we can’t rely on it? What if it never pans out?"
- beerlord 8y agoThe solutions are already in front of us. Solar, wind and gas for electricity. No more coal. Technology already exists. Side effect: cleaner air. Electric cars and trucks for transport. Technology already exists. Side effect: cleaner air and better cars. No more beef. Pork, chicken, insects and plants instead. Technology already exists (has for thousands of years). Side effect: less water use, healthier diets. Mostly these things would come faster with a broad enough carbon tax, instead they are coming slowly. I'm completely certain that we could do all of the above in 5 years. At most the above would entail minor inconveniences for the average person. It just takes the political will to place a minor inconvenience on a population whom you hope will still vote for you.
- dangravell 8y agoHigh performance buildings, both newbuild and retrofit. Another case where the problem is solved technically, but that's not the issue. The issues are organisational, political and other 'soft' reasons which make it more difficult than flicking a switch in a democracy.
- fromthepeople2 8y agoWhat about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_thermal_energy#Molten_salt_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_thermal_energy#Molten_sa... https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=solar+thermal+power https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=solar+thermal+p...
- singularity2001 8y agoIn its argument against solar the article makes on fundamental mistake: It does not take into account that prices for solar-panels are falling exponentially (1/2 every ~6 years).
- mimixco 8y agoEveryone in this post (or any other on HN) that brings up any anti-nuclear facts gets downvoted and I'm sure this comment will be no exception... but here goes. Nuclear is not safe. Every plant has had accidents and leaks. Nuclear power is uninsurable and no insurance company will touch it. Major accidents like Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, and Fukushima cannot be cleaned up at all -- ever. Nuclear is not carbon neutral. Mining and processing uranium use lots of carbon-powered machines. Nuclear waste is a problem still unsolved and, IMHO, unsolvable. And nuclear is not cost effective so it relies on huge government subsidies. Many countries are pulling away from nuclear power for these reasons. A great resource for anyone interested in some facts about nuclear which are not widely discussed should check out Helen Caldicott's book, Nuclear Power is Not The Answer: https://www.amazon.com/Nuclear-Power-Answer-Helen-Caldicott/dp/1595582134 https://www.amazon.com/Nuclear-Power-Answer-Helen-Caldicott/...
- adrianN 8y agoNuclear waste is mostly a political problem. We could build breeder reactors and burn up 99% of the so-called waste, leaving behind only short lived isotopes. We don't because of proliferation fears. I'm also reasonably sure that nuclear still produces a lot less carbon dioxide than coal or gas fired plants, even if you account for mining operations. Safety is indeed a problem, especially with the old designs we're running now. But you have to weigh the risks of localized disasters with the risk of catastrophic climate change. The main problem is the high cost of nuclear plants and the long time it takes to build them. It is entirely unclear whether investing into new plants right now makes sense, or whether we should rather dump the money into battery storage. What doesn't make sense though is turning existing nuclear plants off, as we did for example in Germany, or building new coal plants instead of new nuclear plants because base-load plants are still necessary.
- mimixco 8y agoThe reason it's so expensive and time consuming to build plants is precisely because of the safety issues. This is the elephant in the room when it comes to costs
- 8y ago
- listic 8y agoIs there a non-paywalled version?