3 ms·
It’s not really a comparable situation. US states compete for resources within a national economy. South Korea is a national economy. And California and Kansas
by philwelch 8y ago
It’s not really a comparable situation. US states compete for resources within a national economy. South Korea is a national economy. And California and Kansas differ in many ways other than tax rates. California’s high state taxes are a mechanism for monetizing California’s other economic advantages to fund their state government, while lower state taxes in states like Kansas are a mechanism for attempting to compensate for their other economic disadvantages.
The mistake is in focusing obsessively on any one variable rather than addressing the entire system. California is definitely economically worse off in some ways than alternate-universe-low-tax California, but in exchange they have more tax revenue and hence potentially better schools and highways. It’s all tradeoffs and matters of degree. Confiscatory 90%+ income tax rates were not sustainable after the immediate postwar era, and might have even been a bad idea at the time, but it doesn’t make sense to overreact to that mistake when it’s long been fixed and there are more obvious bottlenecks.