3 ms·
When I took Economics 101 I was told that there was one school that says "taking people's money away will make the economy worse because they know how to spend
by whatshisface 8y ago
When I took Economics 101 I was told that there was one school that says "taking people's money away will make the economy worse because they know how to spend it best," and another school that says, "the economy is powered by money changing hands, so if you take away money that would otherwise have sat around and use it to buy random items, you will force the economy to be more active than it would otherwise have been."
- wbl 8y agoKeynesian stimulus is intertemporal not redistributive.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pazimzadeh 8y agoThe latter makes intuitive sense. If you give money to the poor and needy, they will spend it on things they need (food, cars, etc..) so the money will end up back in corporations' hands anyway.
- dunpeal 8y agoYou are assuming any of that money will end up with the "poor and needy", instead of hiring more bureaucrats whose function is often to hinder economic activity and growth by numerous rules and regulations.
- bluGill 8y agoI reject the idea that money is sitting around idle. Very little is - most people keep a little idle cash in their wallet and a few coins in a jar: the rest is in banks and other investments were the money is not idle it is working. When you take the money away you don't remove it from changing hands, you just remove me from the changing hand. It it good or bad to remove someone from their money? That depends a lot and is subject to lots of complex debate.
- cynicalkane 8y ago> the economy is powered by money changing hands The economy is powered by creation and exchange of value. Money changing hands is mistaking the incentive for the act itself. Most economic schools of thought advocate stimulus during recessions to stop a slowdown of money changing hands, but this is a short-term measure. Money isn't the economy and there's no reason to believe making money fly around willy-nilly will help the economy in a permanent way.
- dunpeal 8y agoExactly. The key factor in growth is the production of goods an services. To easily demonstrate: imagine everyone stopped producing goods and services tomorrow in the US. Everyone would still have the exact same amount of money, but you will not be able to use it to buy a fresh loaf of bread (since none are being baked) or have your car serviced. The value of money will drop to zero. It won't matter at all if it changes hands; indeed, it won't, since there won't be anything to buy. Thinking "money changing hands" powers the economy is thus mistaking effect for a cause.
- nybble41 8y ago> Money changing hands is mistaking the incentive for the act itself. I think there's more to it than that. There is no particular reason to think that money changing hands benefits the economy, or society, but there is at least one party that does benefit: the government. Every time money changes hands the government takes a share in the form of income and/or sales taxes. Ergo, there is reason for the idea that higher monetary velocity is better to be popular among both politicians and the economists who advise them.