3 ms·
Please show me where I can buy thefounder's location data from Google. Which service is that, and how much do I need to pay? I can't find it at https://www.goog
by vkou 8y ago
Please show me where I can buy thefounder's location data from Google. Which service is that, and how much do I need to pay? I can't find it at https://www.google.com/about/products/ https://www.google.com/about/products/
> better said will target you with ads.
The difference between selling location data, and selling ad targeting, is the difference between actively stalking someone, and sending unsolicited spam to "Current resident" at "Every address in a city block".
What harm can I inflict to you, via targeted ads? Some. You can think of some creative ways to do so, but it's not a very effective way to inflict harm.
What harm can I inflict to you, via buying your location data? A hell of a lot.
If you don't trust Google to be a good steward of your data, that's one thing. But let's not conflate selling your data, with selling the ability to mass-advertise to a demographic that includes you.
- pjc50 8y ago> selling the ability to mass-advertise to a demographic that includes you. A while ago there were some fun articles about "how to prank your roommate by creating an audience of 1 and running creepily personalised adverts". What's the smallest demographic you can define on google?
- vkou 8y agoI don't know - which is why I leave the caveat that some creative forms of harm with targeted advertising may be possible.
- lancesells 8y ago> What harm can I inflict to you, via targeted ads? Some. You can think of some creative ways to do so, but it's not a very effective way to inflict harm. Do you see how people have weaponized social media through data? Google ads might not have been used in a nefarious way just yet but that's likely because it hasn't been thought of.
- vkou 8y agoWith ratings, on a scale of one to ten, how would you compare the individual harm of someone showing you a demographic-targeted ad[1], to someone having the real-time location data sufficient to start physically stalking you? What about someone showing you an untargeted ad? Where would that fit in? [1] Or, if you prefer, a remarketing ad, instead. I have very little patience for those.
- taneq 8y agoThe harm to me isn't the harm of someone showing me a demographic-targeted ad, the harm is someone showing everyone demographic-targeted ads designed to manipulate public opinion. Remember how everyone got very hot and bothered about precisely this thing happening in a recent U.S. election?
- vkou 8y agoWhy are cookie-based demographic-targeting ads that manipulate public opinion bad, while demographic-targeting ads on television, in magazines, etc, are fine? Is it because more targeted ad spend is more efficient? If your problem is that advertising is used to manipulate public opinion - consider - why do we even allow political campaigns and paid speech? Its only purpose is to manipulate public opinion, and to trick stupid voters into voting for bad people. I'm afraid your position is not entirely ideologically consistent with how we determine what kind of political speech is allowed, and is not allowed.
- thefounder 8y agoUnless you are on the run the location data is not really that valuable. I could physically stalk you after all without buying the data from telecom companies. With Facebook the advertising can be quite precise. I remeber I read somewhere that you could actually target specific persons.