3 ms·
> The thing in common among everyone I know who is overweight is that they don't even work out at all Exercise does not help people lose weight, and it may mak
by DanBC 8y ago
> The thing in common among everyone I know who is overweight is that they don't even work out at all
Exercise does not help people lose weight, and it may make it harder for people to lose weight.
Exercise is important, and we need to help more people exercise, but we should avoid suggesting that exercise helps weight loss. It does not.
- gamblor956 8y agoThat's extremely wrong and dangerous advice. Exercise is absolutely essential for healthy weight loss unless your sole focus is on lost mass. Exercising while dieting (meaning restricting calories) minimizes the loss of muscle tissue when trying to lose >1 lb/week. If you're losing >2lb/week dieting without exercise, a sizable portion of the weight loss is actually muscle. It is possible to take the exercise to an unhealthy extreme, such as on Biggest Loser, where they exercised to the point of causing muscle damage/rhabo, but that's the exceptional case, not the norm. Exercise absolutely helps weight loss. 100%.
- parasubvert 8y agoIt is not wrong advice. It is not dangerous. Exercise is essential for health. From a purely scientific numbers perspective, it has little impact on weight loss in the morbidly obese. The vast majority of impact is from food consumption. Too much Aerobic exercise can be detrimental to weight loss as it encourages metabolic slow down and increases cravings for easy energy. It also has near zero impact on preserving lean body mass. Modest aerobic activity is always healthy, but in the morbidly obese, any more than that is counter productive. Weight lifting on the other hand does have a major impact on preserving lean body mass during a diet, but it also depends on you eating a lot of protein. Without the protein, you’re also not going to be conserving lean body mass. Again, what you eat is the most important. You can lose trmeendous fat , water, and muscle mass purely by eating less. It’s going to be fat-loss with with 20-30 minutes of walking 5 days a week, and some modest dumbbells or resistance band work, and a decent amount of lean protein ingestion.
- parthdesai 8y agoDo you have any sources to back you up? I was never obese, but i definitely was on the "healthier" side back in the day (~182 pounds at 5'8"). Going to gym and running or working out gives you a perspective of how much work you need to do to burn even 100 calories. Iirc, A can of coke contains ~160 calories, two oreo cookies contain around that amount as well. Once you start thinking about how many calories you need to burn to eat those things, your diet becomes significantly healthier. And before someone says anything about not being able to control themselves, i will still finish an entire pack of cookies in one sitting if i buy them. What has helped me is not to buy them outright itself.
- watwut 8y agoIt definitely did not worked for me that way. I was never obese, but exercise like lifting weight made me more hungry and that was pretty much impact of it on food. The diet did not became healthier at all - just bigger.
- parthdesai 8y agoWell yeah, they say weight loss starts in the kitchen/80% of gym is in the kitchen/abs are made in the kitchen. If you aren't informed of what you eat then it's not gonna make a difference. Though your heart will thank you for exercising.