3 ms·
I would say that this is true in cases when neglecting to exercise and eat appropriately is the cause of excess weight in a normally functioning body. In sever
by kazinator 8y ago
I would say that this is true in cases when neglecting to exercise and eat appropriately is the cause of excess weight in a normally functioning body.
In severe cases of obesity, something else may be going on. In a nutshell, the bodies of some of these sufferers could be on some sort of fat storage rampage. The fat cells extract an "energy tax" and store it; the body then has to do with what is left.
If there is a broken, runaway fat storage mechanism at play, such that a percentage of your intake is stored as fat, and not easily released again, it will be difficult to overcome the accumulation of fat with diet and exercise.
But, yeah, diet and exercise work for many people. And in many cases when they are reported as not working, they weren't given the proper effort.
Excercise that works is probably 2-3X more voluminous and intense than exercise people think
ought to work, damn it! And sane eating plans have to be adhered to forever, not just for a couple of weeks.
If you stick with exercise and become a long-term dedicated athlete, it will change how the body works. You have to change your self-image into one that includes you as an athlete. A durable, self-image that persists even if you take a break from sport which gives you confidence to get back into the game.
- chrisseaton 8y agoThen how come in famine situations there is nobody for whom the restricted calorie intake and exercise does not cause weight loss? Nobody in those situations stays overweight due to 'some sort of fat storage rampage' do they?
- kazinator 8y agoWell, firstly, "famine" isn't the same thing as "diet and exercise regime" Even if famine does work, and does so for everyone, that still plausibly leaves regular diet and exercise not equally effective for everyone. > Nobody in those situations stays overweight due to 'some sort of fat storage rampage' do they? I actually have no idea. Does there exist anyone who died at close to zero fat and muscle in a death camp, or due to famine, who had been confirmed to have been a 450 pounder? It's imaginable that in such a predicament, such an obese person will die of starvation long before losing the fat; that it simply won't be metabolically available to sustain them. Without any actual data, "nobody came out fat out of Auschwitz" is just a dumb Internet meme. There are cases of incredible body transformation from people quite severely obese to basically skin-over-muscle; yet that doesn't prove it's possible for everyone.