3 ms·
Reading to your kids doesn't seem to help them read more proficiently, at least not on average. The 1994 Scarborough & Dobrich paper on this is one of the most
by Alex3917 16y ago
Reading to your kids doesn't seem to help them read more proficiently, at least not on average. The 1994 Scarborough & Dobrich paper on this is one of the most famous in education literature, and there are a bunch of good responses to it as well.
- JabavuAdams 16y agoI'll check that out, if I have time. The problem I have with a lot of these studies and various parenting advice is that tiny, tiny details matter. Word choice, what you remark on, what you reward, and how you behave by default (as opposed to when consciously teaching) matter so much. Investigations into child psychology should probably teach us a lot about the children, themselves. The problem with investigating parenting is that you really need a 24/7 video log.
- util 16y agoHow about encouraging them to read by themselves?
- stevie 16y agoAfrican-American Harvard economist Roland G. Fryer did that with monetary incentives and found it worked for getting children to not only read, but to do homework as well as achieve higher marks on tests.
- stevie 16y agoI think this is wrong. Reading does help, but it has to done in the correct way, like much else to do with education in general. The Success For All study done in 2006: "Conclusion The quantity and quality of research on Success for All, and the positive outcomes found in almost all studies by more than fi fty investigators in eighteen different research institutions worldwide, clearly establish that Success for All is highly effective in increasing student reading. The effects can be quite substantial, averaging more than half of the national white-minority achievement gap and almost a full grade equivalent by second grade (see Slavin et al., 2006). In a time when educators are increasingly being asked to use proven programs, Success for All is the best demonstration in existence of the idea that rigorous research on practical programs can be done and can show substantial positive effects. Every child should have a right to participate in a program with this level of evidence."
- Alex3917 16y agoRight, that's why I said 'at least not on average'. If you are asking your kids questions while you read that are phrased in the proper way then there is benefit, but most people wouldn't do that unless they were trained to.