4 ms·
Ask HN: Thought experiment on how to disrupt public education
Ref: https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/Los-Angeles-Teachers-Strike-Pushed-Back-To-Monday-504167821.html
Teachers Unions are taking schools hostage. This is literally not unlike asking for a ransom. ‘Work to rule’ and strike threats brewing in Bay Area too.
How can public education be revamped? We have so much technology but nothing has changed in recent times.
(At least in CA. I am not sure about other places)
- brad0 8y ago- offer better incentives/pay: Right now in Australia no one who does well in school goes into teaching. The demand is there so universities bring in people who get 20/100 on their high school scores. - change the format of education: kids are more anxious than ever (see current HN front page). There’s no guarantee that you will be okay financially with the current education system.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoGood points. But is education always about financial security? Do we need teachers in their traditional or rather in their current roles? Should the way of knowledge transmission be altered? What would happen when there are less jobs to fill and more human population? What is the role of education and work when automation spreads? I guess we will have to go back to definitions: What is knowledge? What is education? What is the purpose of knowledge? What is the purpose of education?
- oldmancoyote 8y agoThere is alway room for improvement, but education requires constant thoughtful observation and adjustments. When I talk to my sister who was a teacher, I am impressed about the deep thinking that went into adjusting the education of each of her students. I don't see technology helping this very much.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI think children learn more from peers than from books or teachers. If children are formed as groups so an older child is in charge of younger ones and younger ones are responsible for those under them and so on, knowledge transfer is both ways. Now older kids have to learn and be teachers to their younger students. It seems to be a better system. Technology can help to cluster students appropriately so they learn and teach from each other. My 2c.
- ddingus 8y agoThis can be true, and not true. How students learn varies a lot more than many of us want to admit. It is best to have a variety of means available, and multiple opportunities for students tonpresent how they learn.
- ddingus 8y agoIt is human work. Reach the students, understand who they are, tease out what they can become... Your sister is an increasingly rare bird. So many lack time, resources, agency to do that. Nearly all of the educators were able to do that for me. 70's 80's I find the lack of agency, and standard, often teach to test, load shocking. Much reduced agency in many cases.
- oldmancoyote 8y agoIt appears that the censors have struck again and remove a thoughtful and fair-minded discussion. I have had enough I will never again contribute to HN.
- yesenadam 8y agoAw, not sure why you say that. What was removed? I enjoyed reading this page, and particularly what you wrote.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI wonder too. Was it something I said?
- yesenadam 8y agoI don't think so, your interactions were impressively civil. I think maybe it was that a lot of your comments on this page were being grayed out, something he evidently had a problem with recently. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18861861 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18861861
- tmaly 8y agoI really enjoyed the discussion on this post as I have children and I want the best for their future. I would like to see more discussion on this topic.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI was thinking about Neal Stephenson’s Diamond Age. What if every child has a cloned AI in the form of a robot or a tablet etc. it mirrors the child’s knowledge base. And depending on the life circumstances of the child, every choice the child has to make, it offers a variety of subjects to learn and master. In the future, there are no ‘degrees’ ..only skills that are marketable. I find it difficult to believe that we will have a job market as we know it now for the future generations. What is education for then...if we do end up in a post scarcity world..education still has value, yes? OTOH, if we end up with a resource scarce world, survivability would be based on skill sets that are not salary based. Just wool gathering here. What kind of future do you think your kids will have and what kind of education do you think they’d need in their future?
- oldmancoyote 8y agoHow do you disrupt public education? You do what certain political activists have done during the past 70 or so years. 1) You relax the laws that require public education using the rubric that private schools will allow for competition and force improvement. It is no accident that fewer families dependent of public schools weakens support for public schools. It also means that political and religious agendas can be entered into American education where before they were forbidden. 2) You couple that with a long term propaganda campaign about how bad public schools are including portraying teacher union activists in the worst possible light in the news. 3) You starve funding for education to the point where, for example, California goes from the foremost example of excellence in education to one of the worst. 4) When teachers start to rebel at the corruption of American education, you vilify teachers claiming they are taking American education hostage. The idea that technology offers a solution to a political issue is not realistic.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoWhy are unions a good thing? They seem to hold students as hostages and at random. It’s pretty gnarly. CA unfunded pension liabilities may be around $100 trillion https://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherburnham/2018/07/30/three-cheers-for-the-los-angeles-times/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherburnham/2018/07/30/t... It has made CA into a nanny state. Gov. Newsom now wants to provide pre school education for the first four years. Where is the money for all this? After school tutoring classes have become a cottage industry in affluent cities. In low income districts, schools are everything from day care to free meals. Meanwhile school funding is highest in low income districts (LAUSD is 17.xxk per student ..OUSD is 14.5k/student) and on the lower scale in affluent areas(Bay Area: 8-9k/student) as property tax and general fund gets redistributed. Which is fine as society must bear the burden of educating all. But it seems like it’s all going for the care and feeding of union backed retired teachers. Unions have become so powerful that in LA, it’s a strike. In Fremont, teachers refusing to do more their hours...in Oakland...well. That’s a huge can of worms that no one can understand or fix. I don’t even know where to start with Oakland’s problems. So clearly throwing money at ‘public education’ isn’t working because there isn’t a whole lot of educating going on for that money. Interestingly there is just one school district that isn’t unionized. Clovis Unified School District. It’s near Fresno. If you google it, there is some fascinating info there. And yes, they are doing very well. I am reminded of the 2010 documentary, “Waiting for Superman”
- WheelsAtLarge 8y agoUse technology to reduce the size of the teaching groups and tailor the curriculum towards what the kids like and will be happy to learn. Each group would be about 5-6 kids in size and one of the kids would be the team leader also they would work together throughout the year. The teacher would teach the class but groups would work together to learn the assigned work. The teacher would manage the groups and be available to help. Tech would help reduce the teacher's paperwork and help reinforce the materials thru video. Why the groups? It would make it easier to manage unruly kids thru peer pressure and identify kids that are falling behind and challenge those that learn faster. I would also design the curriculum so that kids will have some kind of career skill by the time they graduate high school. Preparing kids for college is not enough. They should have a skill plus they can continue to college if they like. It's shameful that kids can go thru 12years of school yet not be able to earn a living- at the very least learn to give haircuts. Also, kids should be able to tailor their assigned work towards what they like thru tech. Example, say I like electronics then part of my day would include a project that applies what I learned in school by doing a big project in electronics. Schools have become a place to babysit kids while their parents work. I also think that 12 years of school is probably too many years of school. The last three should be used to start learning what they want to be in life. Also, parents need to be part of the equation. Parents want to blame the schools and the teachers if their kids fall behind but the parents need to figure out what the problem is and get the help the kids need. The parents have the ultimate responsibility for making sure their kids learn. In short, parents will be assigned responsibilities along with the kids.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoA lot of what you said resonates with me. I don’t disagree.
- tmaly 8y agoParents absolutely have to be part of the learning. If both parents work and make no time to contribute to the development of the child's abilities, the outcome is obvious.
- rankandfile 8y agoDon't be a scab!