6 ms·
Proficiency of Black Students Is Found to Be Far Lower Than Expected
- asmithmd1 16y agoI started to develop a little skepticism when I came across this quote: "In college, black men represented just 5 percent of students in 2008." Isn't that exactly how many you would expect based on the demographics of the US?
- Alex3917 16y agoWell by the time you get to the NYT article you're on the third layer of overlapping propaganda, after NAEP and the CGCS. But since most HN readers aren't interested in reading through the hundreds of pages of methodology for the NAEP, you just have to take pretty much the whole thing with a grain of salt.
- nickpinkston 16y agoWikipedia says they're 14% of US population - I'm not sure how the age distribution is, but that's plenty high enough to show a problem.
- billpaetzke 16y agoBut the stat is about black men only--excluding women. So 7% then. Is 5% actual vs 7% desired a big enough gap to cause alarm? I don't know.
- kmak 16y agoI suppose it depends on the way you're framing it. If it gets to 7% as desired, it is 40% more!
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- billpaetzke 16y agoBlacks account for 13% of the population, according to US Census estimates of 2009 (39.6 mil / 307 mil). (Now, we only want to look at 18-25 yr olds, but I don't have that data. So we have to assume equal distribution among age ranges). And let's say, of that 13%, half are men and half are women. So, it would be "normal" if 6.5% of college students are black men. 5% vs 6.5% doesn't seem like a HUGE problem. Data source: http://www.factfinder.census.gov/servlet/DTTable?_bm=y&-geo_id=01000US&-ds_name=PEP_2009_EST&-_lang=en&-redoLog=false&-mt_name=PEP_2009_EST_G2009_T003_2009&-format=&-CONTEXT=dt http://www.factfinder.census.gov/servlet/DTTable?_bm=y&-...
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- JabavuAdams 16y agoI suspect that home and community culture is the main reason, and race is somewhere off in the noise. I'd like to see research on different home cultures. I'd especially like to see a way to assign a metric to a family to rate how "scholarly" the environment is for the children. You couldn't ask people directly, because pretty much every parent will agree with the statement: "We think education is important." It's just that a lot of them don't translate that into action. E.g. "What, why would you read to a 1 year old? They can't understand it." Instead, go to substantive things like: 1) How often did you read to your child at age 0-3 months 2) When did your child first start watching TV? 3) Do you have books or magazines in the house? 4) Do you read with your kids every day? ...
- Alex3917 16y agoReading to your kids doesn't seem to help them read more proficiently, at least not on average. The 1994 Scarborough & Dobrich paper on this is one of the most famous in education literature, and there are a bunch of good responses to it as well.
- JabavuAdams 16y agoI'll check that out, if I have time. The problem I have with a lot of these studies and various parenting advice is that tiny, tiny details matter. Word choice, what you remark on, what you reward, and how you behave by default (as opposed to when consciously teaching) matter so much. Investigations into child psychology should probably teach us a lot about the children, themselves. The problem with investigating parenting is that you really need a 24/7 video log.
- util 16y agoHow about encouraging them to read by themselves?
- stevie 16y agoAfrican-American Harvard economist Roland G. Fryer did that with monetary incentives and found it worked for getting children to not only read, but to do homework as well as achieve higher marks on tests.
- Towle_ 16y agoThe more excuses any given demographic has available to it, the worse it will fare.
- maxklein 16y agoThat's a terribly dismissive thing to say about people who are just one generation away from not being able to vote because they were born darker than others.
- Towle_ 16y agoIt should be noted that it matters not whether those excuses are valid. When an entire group buys into the idea, correctly or incorrectly, that their lack of success is someone else's fault, the group as a whole stops trying at all. "What's the point in trying? They won't let us succeed." edit 1: A strong, telling corollary is that forced immigrant groups always fare poorer than willful immigrant groups. Always. edit 2: How many generations removed from communist tyranny are America's Chinese and Taiwanese immigrants? How're they doing?
- maxklein 16y ago'Communist tyranny' as you term it, is very different from systematic racism. I doubt that the attitude of 'they won't let us' is really without merit - just 20 years ago, MTV would not play music by black artists. Black America has come vey far, and is one of the most dominant cultural forces on the planet. That's for the peak of the society. The bottom of the society still has to deal with a lot of legacy problems, and attitudes like yours don't help the problem. I doubt that the majority of problems comes from a sense of entitlement, like you strangely enough, seem to believe.
- zeteo 16y agoThe average citizen under a communist tyranny had far, far worse problems than being denied suffrage. Read The Gulag Archipelago and The Black Book of Communism for an idea of the horrible sufferings that the Soviet Union imposed on its citizens.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]