5 ms·
> Is there any source to back up this claim that life is getting more difficult for Americans? I'd posit that life hasn't been getting more difficult, but that
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
> Is there any source to back up this claim that life is getting more difficult for Americans?
I'd posit that life hasn't been getting more difficult, but that it feels like it has become more difficult, largely because it's harder to advance your current socioeconomic status than it used to be (ie, "the hill is getting steeper"). This is also what makes the analogy particularly strong.
When you're used to accelerating growth, no growth or even constant growth feels like a downgrade.
- manfredo 8y agoI'm not sure what you mean by saying it's harder to"advance your current socioeconomic status". The Economist article I linked to gave evidence that people's purchasing power has been and continues to be increasing. In other words, stuff that was expensive for average people not so long ago is affordable for them now. If "socioeconomic status" is defined as income or asset percentile, then that is inherently a zero sum goal. For someone to go from the middle third of Americans by income into the top third means that someone in the top third has to go into the middle third (or bottom third).
- michaelchisari 8y agoIn other words, stuff that was expensive for average people not so long ago is affordable for them now. For consumer goods, absolutely. For other things, it's gotten much worse. Healthcare and education obviously being one of the biggest concerns. When I graduated high school in 1997, the local community college's tuition was $17 a credit hour ($26 in today's dollars). That small community college in the middle of nowhere is now $128 a credit hour for in-district students. That's almost a 5x increase. For the same local community college amongst corn fields two hours from anything. There's so many examples of this (rent, for instance) that I almost wonder what the point of pointing out the low cost of consumer goods would be. The price of a life well lived has little to do with the price of smartphones.
- manfredo 8y agoSure, some things have gotten more expensive while others have gotten cheaper. But the quantitative analysis seems to indicate that in aggregate things are getting cheaper. I'm not sure how listing a handful of personal examples is a good response to a statement grounded in data.
- michaelchisari 8y agoin aggregate things are getting cheaper I'm pointing out that is a naive analysis.
- manfredo 8y agoAnd I'm pointing out that scores of people are calling this analysis naive, whithout sources to back up such a claim, in the face of multiple sources that say that incomes adjusted to purchasing power are at least the same if not improving. I don't doubt the veracity of your personal experiences with rising rents and education costs, but the plural of anecdote isn't data.
- michaelchisari 8y agoIt's pretty well undisputed that health care, rent and education have far eclipsed inflation and especially not kept track with wages and income. Here's a simple source for reference, but there are plenty more if you stick to those metrics: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/21/life-is-much-more-expensive-for-you-than-it-was-for-your-parents.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/06/21/life-is-much-more-expensive-... https://www.cnbc.com/2017/04/24/things-are-more-expensive-than-they-were-10-years-ago.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/04/24/things-are-more-expensive-th... Now what we're arguing here isn't facts. Both of us are making true statements: You're saying the aggregate cost-of-living is not that much higher. I'm saying the necessities of health care, housing and education are hugely off track. What we're disagreeing about is the philosophical interpretation of those facts. I'm saying it hardly matters if mobile phones are cheaper every year, if health care is more expensive. An aggregate doesn't take into account the relative weights of importance. Not to mention the fact that wages and income are stagnant. That's a whole other issue that multiplies the concern.