6 ms·
> There is no blurry line here. Child abuse and child pornography are clearly defined terms. Justifying child abuse in a novel might be morally offensive, but i
by dragontamer 8y ago
> There is no blurry line here. Child abuse and child pornography are clearly defined terms. Justifying child abuse in a novel might be morally offensive, but is not a crime, abusing an actual child however, and publishing footage of it, is.
Okay, let me give an alternative situation then.
A 14 year old girl sends a sexual text message to her (also underage) boyfriend. In Minnesota, the 14-year-old-girl was charged with Child Pornography.
https://www.aclu.org/blog/juvenile-justice/minnesota-prosecutor-charges-sexting-teenage-girl-child-pornography https://www.aclu.org/blog/juvenile-justice/minnesota-prosecu...
If you think morality is black-and-white, then you are going to cause issues to many people. There's nothing "black and white" about distributing child porn. There are unfortunately, a ton of gray areas.
Yes, there are clear-cut cases of CP that need to be banned. But you must ALWAYS be wary about the edge cases, lest you harm otherwise innocent people. A 14-year-old who sends naked pictures of herself to her friends is... well... objectionable, but it shouldn't result in a sex-crime on her permanent record.
- gammateam 8y agoMinnesota’s criminal statute would have absolutely nothing to do with any federal statute or any other state’s criminal statute Good news! If you are rich enough to pay and keep paying your lawyers then you can move the case to the federal venue either immediately or in appeals court. Now we have a standardized venue to actually discuess any gray areas or lack thereof That’ll be $2000 for this “hour” of work to afford your freedom, thanks
- jkartchner 8y agoYou can't "remove" your state criminal case to federal court. You've confused a civil case with a criminal case brought by the state.
- gammateam 8y agoThats pretty interesting, it seems there have been some narrow circumstances for removal of criminal cases from state to federal venue but not a viable option like in civil cases
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoThis is the way it must be. Otherwise an underage person could, say, send nude photos of herself to all her teachers, call the FBI, and have them all arrested while she faces no penalty. If simply having the file on your computer is illegal, then any creator of this content, no matter what his or her age, must be liable.
- DanBC 8y agoThere's no public interest in prosecuting a 15 year old who willingly sends an image of themself to another 15 year old. It's a fucking stupid thing for them to do, but criminal justice system isn't the solution for that.
- hopler 8y agoSo it's not the way it must be, if the existing insane laws are repealed.
- kiriakasis 8y agoNope, if I hide cocaine in your house the crime is mine. If person X send person Y unsolicited CP with the intention of calling the police on them I am pretty sure X is committing a crime. It might be hard for Y to prove this though.
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoThat's not the way the law works with illegal pornography. There is no legal defense to possession.
- wolco 8y agoThey could be charged by making sending pictures of themselves to themselves.