3 ms·
I was appalled by the idea that kids in grade 9 are supposed to be taking clusters of classes for career preparation. What happened to getting a broad educatio
by gumby 8y ago
I was appalled by the idea that kids in grade 9 are supposed to be taking clusters of classes for career preparation. What happened to getting a broad education (especially in high school!) so that you can think about a variety of topics and participate as a member of civic society and have a foundation to be able to learn to do whatever job is useful in the 2030s or 2040s? Kids in the 80s didn't take classes to help them become web developers, but hopefully they got the necessary skills to do that job when it eventually arrived.
==
I went the opposite way with my own kid (do as well as you can in a bunch of subjects, think about which ones you like) to try to prepare him better and spare him a lot of the execution optimization anxiety. As a result: high school was much better for him...but he now has these "what the hell will be my career" and "am I taking the right classes" anxieties in college :-(.
At least he didn't jump in front of a train like a disturbing number of other Palo Alto high schoolers did.
- mrguyorama 8y agoThere is this seemingly comprehensive belief here in America that is utterly embedded in culture and common assumptions that the only value a human life has is to increase the GDP and enrich someone else
- gumby 8y agoThis belief is relatively new (becoming widespread/popular roughly in the early 80s) so could evolve the other way too. I agree it's a corrosive and widespread belief.
- FiveSquared25 8y ago“Greed is good!” - Gordon Gecko
- nugget 8y agoMiddle class American kids are raised to have certain expectations about quality of life - that if they pursue a decent education then they can work 40 hours a week and afford a comfortable house in a safe neighborhood, resources to attract a spouse and build a family, good schools for their kids, and so on. Most wake up in their mid 20s and realize that they have a pile of student loan debt and housing in desirable areas is beyond reach. It's the fundamental disconnect between what society (parents, media, culture) led them to expect and the reality they are confronted with that causes confusion, despair, and anger. Reactions are varied. Some give up, some dig in. The American dream is still alive and well it's just accessed differently than it used to be and we don't talk about that enough with young people. Personally I'm surprised the youngest generations aren't even greedier, more ruthless, and more focused on economic value than they seem to be, based on the structure and incentives of the world into which they were born.
- mjevans 8y agoI grow more resentful and despise the way many will vote for a politician and hope and believe that change will happen, even with no track record to support it. 44 at least got SOME kind of healthcare, but not enough, shoved through before things gridlocked. 45 ... I understand and sympathize with why many followed this siren's call, but it's all emotional rhetoric and very little of real substance. I hope they are replaced soon and move on to making "The East Wing", a reality inspired drama made for TV.
- minikites 8y agoI've stopped asking "What do you do for a living?" when meeting someone new because your occupation should have very little bearing on how interesting or worthwhile you are as a person.
- askafriend 8y agoHow can you meaningfully ignore the thing that people spend most of their time doing? Nearly 60 hours of approximately 110 waking hours in a week are doing something work related. You spend more time in pure hours with coworkers than you do with any other group of people in your life. All of that shapes you as a human being in various ways. Where people work is absolutely important and I don't shy away from talking about work. Even if you're a simple fisherman, that's interesting. It leads to talk about area of expertise, and ultimately talk about the world and perspectives.
- minikites 8y agoIf someone's occupation is important to them, they'll naturally volunteer the information. So many people are underemployed these days or just trying to make ends meet in the "gig economy" that they'd rather talk about anything else in the world. Many people aren't proud of their occupation and it's awkward (bordering on rude) to press them on it.
- eaandkw 8y agoUnder normal circumstances that is't bad. When looking at data statistically it could be very cold hearted. It only becomes a problem when the population begins to worship the state.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> ...but he now has these "what the hell will be my career" and "am I taking the right classes" anxieties in college :-(. I think that's the jist. If schools aren't putting people on a career trajectory all of a sudden they are in university, which costs an arm and a leg, and, as is so often repeated, you're there to get a job, have a focus, and GO. You can't really do that at the drop of a hat if you've never done it before.
- grahamburger 8y agoIt's a reaction to the very common criticism that public education teaches kids things they'll never use and doesn't teach them practical things like how to get a job and do taxes. Both sides have merit, I think.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> What happened to getting a broad education (especially in high school!) so that you can think about a variety of topics and participate as a member of civic society and have a foundation to be able to learn to do whatever job is useful in the 2030s or 2040s? It remains present and as a central motivation, actually, in some (maybe most?) forms of the “career clusters” / “academies” approach, where the career field theme isn't so much about a narrow vocational training focus as providing a unifying interdisciplinary theme across the various classes for small learning communities within larger schools. The educational theory is that the shared interdisciplinary focus (and cross-class activities involving that focus) helps create improved student engagement and that students and faculty being in small learning communities improves identification of and responsiveness to student learning issues that otherwise might skip through the cracks in in a large institution. Presenting this as better preparing students for high-skill, high-wage jobs is perfectly consistent with, though it obviously doesn't immediately evoke, that model—as students who are more engaged and whose educational needs are identified and addressed more effectively are better prepared for such jobs.
- FiveSquared25 8y agoBut do stuff like math, debate, auto shop, computer lab time for computer programming or debate, English, and student elections for politics