3 ms·
The article does a major disservice by not tracing the history of software patents. First, in Flook, SCOTUS effectively said that software wasn't patentable, t
by jcranmer 8y ago
The article does a major disservice by not tracing the history of software patents.
First, in Flook, SCOTUS effectively said that software wasn't patentable, the software in question being a controller for a catalytic converter. In Diamond v. Diehr, SCOTUS said that software was patentable insofar as it was part of a larger patentable system, the software in question being a controller for a rubber mold.
Effectively, SCOTUS (in a time-honored tradition) overturned Flook in Diamond v. Diehr while simultaneously emphasizing that it wasn't overturning Flook.
The Federal Circuit then created the infamous State St. ruling, which held that anything was patentable if it produced a "useful, concrete, tangible result." This is generally recognized as the moment when the patent system broke.
In Bilski v. Kappos, SCOTUS again returned to striking down dubious patents. Of particular note, all of the opinions went out of their way to criticize the State St. formulation as exceptionally bad law. They also rejected the CAFC's alternative-to-State-St. formulation of "machine or transformation test" while being unable to articulate what the correct test ought to be. Mayo and Alice, as noted in the article, further slammed both the State St. notion of "pretty much everything you can think up is patentable" and the general class of business patents. At the same time, SCOTUS has been reluctant to fully close out what isn't patentable (so as to avoid accidentally shutting out Next-Big-Technological-Area-That-Really-Needs-Patents) while being unable to articulate what makes something in a really gray area like software able or unable to clear the bar.
The thrust of SCOTUS is pretty damn clear: if your patent is struggling to tie its innovation to something that's pretty clearly patentable under 18th century patent norms, it's not going to be patentable. That it can't formally articulate those guidelines into a coherent, clear statement is unfortunate but completely understandable. Software itself is in a gray area that really could use clarification, but SCOTUS isn't going to do that without an appropriate vehicle to rule on. Someone needs to try to obtain a patent that is clearly novel, useful, and pure software and have its validity challenged, and have this challenge be appealed up to SCOTUS, before you're going to get a decision where SCOTUS may try to decide it.
Bilski, Mayo, and Alice have all shown that several justices are inherently skeptical of software patents, and they've also shown that software patents are of major interest to the wider topic. But SCOTUS is generally unwilling to rule on a question that isn't directly presented and argued before them, so until a case that itself directly involves software patent 101 eligibility (and has no room to rule invalid on 102-104), there is unlikely to be much clarity here.
- brlewis 8y ago>In Diamond v. Diehr, SCOTUS said that software was patentable insofar as it was part of a larger patentable system, the software in question being a controller for a rubber mold. Not true. They said system could be patentable despite having software as a component. This is common sense. If an invention includes a pulley, a wheel, and a lever, you don't evaluate what's there if those non-novel elements are removed; you look at the whole system. SCOTUS said to look at the system as a whole, including the software. But the novelty and non-obviousness have to exist in the system as a whole. If it's only novel and non-obvious in the software, generally speaking, no patent. They did allow for the possibility that patentable software might possibly exist, but the gist of the ruling is that they hadn't seen such software yet. Also that it was up to congress to clarify, because they didn't feel 100% comfortable deciding if software could possibly be patentable. So they basically stopped a millimeter short of saying software couldn't be patented at all, and the State St ruling stuck a crowbar in that crack.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]