3 ms·
Newspaper science writing works on much the same basis as natural selection - its role is to engage readers first and foremost and succeeds in reproducing the c
by notahacker 8y ago
Newspaper science writing works on much the same basis as natural selection - its role is to engage readers first and foremost and succeeds in reproducing the content in their minds and social media accounts only if it grabs their attention first!
This article is a pretty classic example of that. It starts with misconceptions about what evolution is and the cliche of the brave scientists criticised by the establishment for even raising the possibility of sexual selection. Then it moves on to acknowledging that not only had sexual selection theory has been around since Darwin but it was frequently discussed until eventually support was found for hypotheses that aesthetic preferences animals had evolved to acquire were likely correlated with traits [originally] useful for survival. Then we get to meet the brave scientist challenging the establishment and conclude that much of his lack of peer approval for his views on beauty might stem from his apparent disinterest in engaging with these theories. Then finally, we're presented with the idea that since even our standards of beauty are down to the evolution of the eye of the beholder, the scientific establishment was probably right all along. The article wouldn't have won the affections of the editor if it had started out with that argument though...
- _cs2017_ 8y agoSo bloody true and so bloody annoying. I started to block the media outlets that do that in my Google "swipe left on pixel home screen" feed or whatever it's called. Until I realized it's a futile struggle and just disabled the feed entirely. I'm really at a loss of where to get my news. So far, I switched to HN comments. If you know of anything better please share!
- lordgrenville 8y agoNo easy answers, but Quanta is definitely one of the better ones. It's funded by a non-profit and writes fairly deep pieces (for a lay audience) on maths, physics and biology.
- _cs2017_ 8y agoAgreed. I actually forgot about it, subscribing now. Ironic that the only good publication is free and has no ads.