3 ms·
Was init?
by tinus_hn 8y ago
Was init?
- insertcredit 8y agoThe complexity of Sysvinit is orders of magnitude less than that of systemd.
- dijit 8y agoThe "sysvinit" binary package has had a total of 2 bug reports tagged "security" filed in Debian's bug tracker. That's over the entire history of the package that goes back to at least 2004. If I extend the search to all packages built from the "sysvinit" source (which includes packages like initscripts and sysvinit-utils), the count increases to 8. (source: https://www.debian.org/Bugs https://www.debian.org/Bugs. I'm not linking to exact queries since they take quite some time and HN has a tendency of taking down Debian's bug tracker)
- nailer 8y agoAlso crond, atd, and various log manipulation tools that systemd replaces.
- zzzcpan 8y agoIt doesn't replace them, it just doesn't use them.
- dijit 8y agoIt supplants them with the same functionality. That's literally the definition of replacement.
- nailer 8y agoIndeed. Not complaining - I don't care for HN karma - but it is very odd that an easily searchable fact is being downvoted on a technical forum.
- yarrel 8y agoIt provides inferior code and interfaces that are used instead of them. So you're correct, in a way.
- tinus_hn 8y agoThen it should be easy to audit!
- lima 8y agoNot if you count in the god-awful shell scripts full of race conditions which it replaced.
- lousken 8y agoNo, but it's far less complex than systemd to the point where you can audit the code yourself and it's battle tested over the years. Also because it's so simple it was shown to us at the university so we've got essential understanding of how it works and I think they're still explaining it instead of systemd.
- josteink 8y agoBut systemd is more than just init. It replaces for instance daemontools, restartd or monit. Are you saying you can trivially audit those?
- lousken 8y agoDoes it fully replace monit? Could you link me more info? From what I could find I didn't see anything like free disk space warnings, web interface etc.
- josteink 8y ago> Does it fully replace monit? Not fully, no but as far as I can tell, it has overlapping responsibilities. My main thought when mentioning it, was automatic restart of services in the case of failure.
- maemilius 8y agoThat's a fair point. However, the parent was responding to whether init - in particular - had been audited. So, bringing up other, larger projects that systemd subsumes is a bit disingenuous, imo.