3 ms·
I suppose ideologically a wealth tax presupposes that all wealth is bad, whereas an inheritance tax just targets unearned wealth. How would a wealth tax differ
by benj111 8y ago
I suppose ideologically a wealth tax presupposes that all wealth is bad, whereas an inheritance tax just targets unearned wealth.
How would a wealth tax differ from a capital gains tax? The net effect would seem to be similar?
- losvedir 8y ago> I suppose ideologically a wealth tax presupposes that all wealth is bad, whereas an inheritance tax just targets unearned wealth. I don't agree with that framing, but even so if you look at the debate about income inequality today, you'll see people have issues even with earned wealth, in astronomical amounts (eg Bezos, Gates, Koch brothers, etc).
- benj111 8y ago"The Koch brothers are the sons of Fred C. Koch, who founded Koch Industries, the second-largest privately held company in the United States" wikipedia "His [Bill Gates] father was a prominent lawyer, and his mother served on the board of directors for First Interstate BancSystem and the United Way. Gates' maternal grandfather was J.W. Maxwell, a national bank president." Also wikipedia. So these aren't exactly people who worked their way up from the gutter. But yes some people probably do have problems with earned income, I still think the distinction is worth it though.
- perfunctory 8y ago> ideologically a wealth tax presupposes that all wealth is bad Isn't it the same as saying that income tax presupposes that all income is bad. We should tax wealth not because wealth is bad but because doing so might have a positive effect on society. > How would a wealth tax differ from a capital gains tax? capital gains tax taxes realised return on capital. wealth tax is based on the total wealth regardless of it's performance.
- benj111 8y agoRe ideology. Its an choice between 2 similar taxes. And there are many, many reasons for structuring taxes. Re captial gains tax. Over the very long term, you would expect your investments to at least track inflation, and you would expect to sell of those investments to buy things. Its not clear to me that these 2 taxes necessarily end up very different. Should we not expect to get at least a flavour of what to expect by looking at capital gains tax?
- perfunctory 8y agoI am curious to see the comparison as well. I suppose one difference is that capital gain tax can be delayed far into the future. Wealth tax could also have a cooling effect on stock market bubbles.
- cr1895 8y agoCapital gains tax might also be a tax deduction due to a loss of capital. With a wealth/asset tax it doesn't matter if you actually gain or lose.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoIt doesn't presuppose that wealth is bad. The tax would just be repayment for creating a society that allows that wealth to exist.
- ameister14 8y agoThat's not really what taxes are for, historically. Paying for the things that everyone uses in common, that's what you get taxed for. That and discouraging unwanted behavior.