5 ms·
So inheritance tax?. Or is there an argument that this is good for society?
by benj111 8y ago
So inheritance tax?.
Or is there an argument that this is good for society?
- netcan 8y agoWhy inheritance, why not just a wealth tax? The problem with wealth, company any capex taxes has tended to be dynamic effects like capital flight. But, those aside, a 1% effective wealth tax on paoer/whiteboard, basically neutralises picketty's r>g, the driving force behind wealth disparities. ^ edit: in that theory
- benj111 8y agoI suppose ideologically a wealth tax presupposes that all wealth is bad, whereas an inheritance tax just targets unearned wealth. How would a wealth tax differ from a capital gains tax? The net effect would seem to be similar?
- losvedir 8y ago> I suppose ideologically a wealth tax presupposes that all wealth is bad, whereas an inheritance tax just targets unearned wealth. I don't agree with that framing, but even so if you look at the debate about income inequality today, you'll see people have issues even with earned wealth, in astronomical amounts (eg Bezos, Gates, Koch brothers, etc).
- benj111 8y ago"The Koch brothers are the sons of Fred C. Koch, who founded Koch Industries, the second-largest privately held company in the United States" wikipedia "His [Bill Gates] father was a prominent lawyer, and his mother served on the board of directors for First Interstate BancSystem and the United Way. Gates' maternal grandfather was J.W. Maxwell, a national bank president." Also wikipedia. So these aren't exactly people who worked their way up from the gutter. But yes some people probably do have problems with earned income, I still think the distinction is worth it though.
- perfunctory 8y ago> ideologically a wealth tax presupposes that all wealth is bad Isn't it the same as saying that income tax presupposes that all income is bad. We should tax wealth not because wealth is bad but because doing so might have a positive effect on society. > How would a wealth tax differ from a capital gains tax? capital gains tax taxes realised return on capital. wealth tax is based on the total wealth regardless of it's performance.
- benj111 8y agoRe ideology. Its an choice between 2 similar taxes. And there are many, many reasons for structuring taxes. Re captial gains tax. Over the very long term, you would expect your investments to at least track inflation, and you would expect to sell of those investments to buy things. Its not clear to me that these 2 taxes necessarily end up very different. Should we not expect to get at least a flavour of what to expect by looking at capital gains tax?
- perfunctory 8y agoI am curious to see the comparison as well. I suppose one difference is that capital gain tax can be delayed far into the future. Wealth tax could also have a cooling effect on stock market bubbles.
- cr1895 8y agoCapital gains tax might also be a tax deduction due to a loss of capital. With a wealth/asset tax it doesn't matter if you actually gain or lose.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoIt doesn't presuppose that wealth is bad. The tax would just be repayment for creating a society that allows that wealth to exist.
- ameister14 8y agoThat's not really what taxes are for, historically. Paying for the things that everyone uses in common, that's what you get taxed for. That and discouraging unwanted behavior.
- bloak 8y agoValuing assets is difficult. Doing it every year would be infeasible. Doing it at the point when someone dies and their estate is distributed is much easier. In a lot of cases assets will be auctioned off anyway so you get a valuation for free. (But there must be a lot of cases in which someone sells for a large sum of money a work of art or a copyright that they inherited and people then think: Hang on, was the value of that thing taken account of when the estate was distributed? Should additional inheritance tax be applied now, even though X years have passed and we really can't guess what the value would have been at auction X years ago?)
- asah 8y agoIs it though? - land and real estate (commercial and residential): already valued and taxed annually ! - company stock is re-valued on a regular basis as part of the audit process. - commodities like gold etc - easy - possessions like art, boats etc - small % of wealth except in the most expensive items, which can be appraised every few years, just like real estate. seriously: what else is there?
- bloak 8y agoIf the government were to start taxing people on the value of their assets you can be quite sure that within a year or so most rich people would have their assets in a form that makes it much harder to value them. But there's a problem also for ordinary people, who have most of their assets in the form of their house. In the UK land isn't valued annually.* Unless your house is very similar to a nearby one that was sold recently, nobody really knows what it's worth. Speculation concerning what development might be permitted in the future can have a big influence on the value. It would be scary if some bureaucrat's guess were to significantly affect one's annual tax bill. And it would be expensive for everyone if that resulted in disputes going to court. * Local taxation is based on the "rateable value" of property, but this is inaccurate, banded, often out-of-date, and only a small part of a typical family's total outgoings.
- davidgay 8y ago> If the government were to start taxing people on the value of their assets you can be quite sure that within a year or so most rich people would have their assets in a form that makes it much harder to value them. Switzerland, which tends to be viewed as a haven for the rich, has a wealth tax. It would appear to be a counterexample... Note that it has other tax features which may make it appealing to the rich (no capital gains tax, e.g.).
- bsbechtel 8y agoTaking away the ability for those who can take longer term risks doesn't really do anything to help those who don't have that opportunity. The total income brought in from inheritance taxes isn't really enough to create a society wide impact on this type of problem either.
- benj111 8y agoThe longer term risk argument is interesting, but my pension investments would say otherwise. Also even if its 'only' zero sum, that money is still going somewhere, either allowing someone else to make a long term investment, or something more immediate. What would you say are the "society wide impacts"? I tend to subscribe to the view that money is the root of all evil[1], so at the extreme, a 100% inheritance rate would solve the problem. [1]In the sense that money leads to power, increased education opportunities for children etc etc.
- kiriakasis 8y agoInequality is way deeper than money; finding blame in capitalism is alright, if you want to fight inequality and corruption you have a wildly different enemy than mere money
- benj111 8y agoI agree. My personal view is earned wealth is more acceptable than inherited wealth. And that entrenched money is a significant contributing factor to certain types of corruption and inequality. If the Son never inherited the Fathers money, he'll have to earn his own before bribing that politician.
- kadabra9 8y agoSo what should the father do? Just give his money to the state when he dies? Spend it all?
- 8y ago
- wsc981 8y agoNo point. The very wealthy can find very good ways to avoid such taxes, e.g. through creating foundations, businesses, etc… I believe this is one of the reasons why wealthy families often create some foundation. It allows one to put their children on the payrol, keep money in the family and prevent any outsiders to gain access to this capital through marriage, etc… You could invest most of the money and spend a minor amount on charity each year, allowing the capital to grow and avoid paying taxes. Money donated to the foundation is in many countries tax free as well, so it's another nice way to avoid paying too much income tax.
- bayesian_horse 8y agoWhat you describe is the Trump Foundation to a T. Whose conduct has been called criminal...
- wsc981 8y agoI'm sure it not much different from the Clinton Foundation.
- benj111 8y agoFoundations are a tool to encourage the rich to 'donate' money though. Theres nothing in principle to stop the state from increasing the arm length that the foundation should be held at, although that may lead to a loss of 'charitable' donations. I'm not sure theres no point to taxes even if they're avoided. At the very least it sends a signal about what society finds acceptable.
- iguy 8y ago> So inheritance tax?. Or is there an argument that this is good for society? Why is this binary? It could be terrible for society, and something which an inheritance tax cannot cure. Or something awful for which cures would be worse. We could eliminate most cancers from society if we shot everybody on their 60th birthday... but few would regard this as an improvement. Ditto Maoism, etc. But there are other more incremental things we can, and do, try against cancer.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoI don't know about the US but in the UK a land value tax looks quite attractive. For one thing it's almost impossible to avoid, you can't shift land to a low tax regime. I'm not sure we will ever knowingly vote for it though.
- benj111 8y agoWould a land value tax necessarily target wealth? That wealthy billionaire with 5 yatchs and a private jet may not own any land. Yes they would probably be hit with increased rent on the rented flat, but that would tend to hit everyone to some degree. Wouldn't a land value tax essentially end up like an expanded council tax?
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoYachts and jets depreciate quickly, I'm not sure they are a problem. Land however is something we all need to live on and off of.
- randyrand 8y agoThe ability to give your wealth onto your children is an important motivator for older people to continue to have purpose, work, and be productive members of society. Put yourself in the life of a 65 year old with adult children. How would you feel about 80% of your death-day savings being taxed? What different choices would you make in your last decades as opposed to today?