By that argument google's index of data isn't the user's data it's google's but the right to be forgotten is specifically about deleting other people's copies o

By that argument google's index of data isn't the user's data it's google's but the right to be forgotten is specifically about deleting other people's copies of data about a person. In particular the NYTimes reports on Joe Baddy doing something bad. That article arguably belongs to the NYTimes. Google indexes that article with permission from NYTimes. Right to be forgotten requires Google remove the link to NYTimes even though neither Google's index nor the article at NYTimes belong to user.