4 ms·
I'm pretty sure this is going to kill Mongo as a company dead. With this in existence there's literally no reason to use Atlas. If they wanted to twist the kni
by XorNot 8y ago
I'm pretty sure this is going to kill Mongo as a company dead. With this in existence there's literally no reason to use Atlas.
If they wanted to twist the knife they should get to work implementing a pass through migration option.
- _wmd 8y agoMongoDB still have a strong hand - control of the client and particularly its exposed featureset - due to that, also control of the protocol and the ability to, for example, insert legally protected strings in the style of the Apple SMC signature into the handshake. - ability to gate new features on the presence of an object like a copyrighted text, trademark, or even a crypto signature - ownership of the name. AWS are pissing in Mongo's pool marketing themselves as compatible, and there are a variety of ways it could be made to backfire, if it were in Mongo's interests to encourage that outcome - AWS focuses on breadth and very rarely nails any particular service. Their hosted Postgres for example still does not expose core features years later - Following from that, AWS services on the whole are rarely best-in-class in terms of raw performance. I imagine Mongo could continue to easily compete on benchmark results running on AWS own infrastructure I think this is a really interesting case, far more interesting than the technical minutia of Just Yet Another AWS service. It does not sit well with me whatsoever that they're basically ripping off a much smaller company's core tech while simultaneously borrowing their trademark (in a legally acceptable manner) as part of the marketing, but I also find it hard not to see a ton of potential upside from this for Mongo
- ec109685 8y agoThe client change would never work. The client is licensed as lgpl, so if they tried to pull any funny business like that, it would be instantly forked and if’d out.
- _wmd 8y agoAs the person suggesting it, it's difficult to imagine how it could never work considering I haven't managed to figure out all the possible combinations in which such a strategy could be applied. Finally, it is quite exasperating to call this kind of strategy "funny business" in a thread about their core tech being ripped off by a megacorp
- ec109685 8y agoTheir API is core tech? That’s like saying there shouldn’t be separate implementations of Java, right?
- AmericanChopper 8y agoMongo and Amazon are both large companies, but mongo are the only ones here trying to stiff their customers. Selling a product that uses open source software is not ripping anybody off, and the only party in this situation who are upholding open source values are Amazon. The only thing I can take away from this is that if I get too successful using Mongo technology, that they’re happy to change their license to try extort money from me. I find this to be especially greasy since open source product like this become successful because of their open source nature. They exist because the community that exists around them, and for them to turn around and decide to spit in our faces by dictating how we can consume the product just makes me hope their product is forked and that they go under.
- alittletooraph 8y agoHave you heard of Amazon Elasticsearch Service, launched in 2015? Elastic is doing fine.
- scarface74 8y agoElastic Co isn’t profitable by definition it isn’t “doing fine”. From their SEC filing: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1707753/000119312518266861/d588632ds1.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1707753/000119312518... We have a history of losses and may not be able to achieve profitability or positive cash flows on a consistent basis. If we cannot achieve profitability or positive cash flows, our business, financial condition, and results of operations may suffer.
- alittletooraph 8y agoYou're right they're not profitable — and neither is MongoDB — but the point is that AWS launched an Elasticsearch service 3 years prior to Elastic having a very successful IPO supported by stellar metrics (also found in the SEC filing you linked). So the statements made at the beginning of this thread are probably a bit premature.
- scarface74 8y agoOnly in tech do people think that a money losing company is “successful” because they were able to convince investors to buy stock instead of defining success as having a business model where income is greater than expenses. In reality long term profitability is the only metric that matters for a corporation
- privateSFacct 8y agoAnd in contrast to these startups with their "success" AWS is printing cash for amazon which releases surprisingly few "metrics" beyond $ in and $ out.
- 8y ago