3 ms·
I didn't read it that way at all. > Do I think that letting a baby starve to death because it is basically a parasite is morally desirable: no. I read that a
by AnimalMuppet 8y ago
I didn't read it that way at all.
> Do I think that letting a baby starve to death because it is basically a parasite is morally desirable: no.
I read that as saying that as using their wording, not as agreeing with their viewpoint.
> Do I find the idea of trying to deduce an entire ethical framework from first principles fascinating and the way it is done interesting: yes
I read that as saying that the the attempt was interesting, in an intellectual way, not saying that we should consider the resulting ethical framework at all. I read it as rejecting the resulting ethical framework in the previous quote.
Can I prove that my reading is right and yours is wrong? No. But I do note that HN guidelines require interpreting others' words charitably.
- stillbourne 8y agoThere is no way to interpret AnCap charitably. It's like asking me to interpret antivax nonsense or climate denial charitably. And it should be met with the same incredulity and ridicule. While we're at it let's go ahead and say the holocaust wasn't so bad, because the nonsense that is AnCap will lead to the same ends. And if you want to flag my comments as being against "HN guidelines" go ahead. If they actually evaluate my comments and decide that I am being "uncharitable" then this forum has devolved into what I have always feared it would become. I've been on HN for over 8 years now. I remember when it was just tech news. But the advent of blockchain and bitcoin and its vague relation to technology has brought in a lot of economic quackery and political fringe philosophies along with it. If this is how I get booted so be it. But I will not be silent when people are ok with the endorsement of bullshit as long as the bullshit is stated "charitably" furthermore I can prove that my view of his opinion is correct because of this statement here: >I also like that pretty much everything is readily available on mises.org. I wish all "schools of thought" would be this forward thinking. Let me google something for you that proves my point. http://lmgtfy.com/?q=mises+parasite http://lmgtfy.com/?q=mises+parasite
- davvolun 8y agoIf I say Hitler was clearly a persuasive speaker, does that imply I believe Nazism? Per my understanding, Austrian economics would presumably argue that (1) babies are parasites (2) parasites should be eliminated (3) ergo, babies should be eliminated AnCap CLEARLY comes to the conclusion that babies should not be eliminated, but makes no argument whatsoever on (1) or (2). In other words, if given the presumed premise of Austrian economics, the conclusion is thus flawed. You attributing this intellectual argument to the user as though they were a believer in that school of thought makes no sense to me. This whole conversation is frustrating because I can't find anything notable you've written here which I disagree with other than that you're ascribing AnCap to this point of view. > I also like that pretty much everything is readily available on mises.org. I wish all "schools of thought" would be this forward thinking. "Forward thinking" in terms of making all of their information readily available; not forward thinking in terms of the entire school of thought. And now you're claiming that AnimalMuppet is threatening to report you or get you kicked off HN. No one said that! AnimalMuppet was referencing the guidelines to say, instead of assuming that AnCap would like babies dead, read it assuming that AnCap doesn't want babies dead, and draw your conclusions from there.
- stillbourne 8y agoAnCap doesn't say that babies should be eliminated, just like it doesn't say that poverty should be eliminated. It just say babies born to poverty shouldn't receive an subsidized help from the government because taxes are theft. Which is saying the same thing as let the fuckers die.
- davvolun 8y agoYou say potato, I say potahto. The end result is the same, and not really relevant to my point that I really don't think anyone (in this thread) is arguing for Austrian economic theory, nor do I think anyone is threatening anyone here. Could be wrong, just my opinion.