4 ms·
Warning, controversial opinion: Chinese is too hard to be cost-effective to learn. I took 3 years' worth of Mandarin in college. But when I traveled to Brazil
by crazygringo 8y ago
Warning, controversial opinion: Chinese is too hard to be cost-effective to learn.
I took 3 years' worth of Mandarin in college.
But when I traveled to Brazil, I was able to communicate more easily in Portuguese in just a month, than I was in China after 2 full years of courses plus two and a half months of intensive courses in Beijing.
Chinese is hard because it has virtually zero cognates with English, you have to learn every word new. (Contrast with Portuguese, where I "knew" half the words already because I could easily guess that "television" is just "televisão". Same with French, Italian, etc.)
And Chinese is hard because you have to learn how to "spell" every word separately -- if you thought zero cognates was hard, this is 10x harder.
Quite frankly it's an insane time commitment, and unless you plan to live most of your life in China or Taiwan, it's just not worth it if your goal is communication. Chinese people are learning English so they can communicate with the world. It might seem unfair, but there's just zero practical reason for most English speakers to learn Chinese beyond some basic greetings, except as a fun hobby or some minimum vocabulary for travel.
For more info, read the very famous article "Why Chinese Is So Damn Hard". [1] Anybody who wants to learn Chinese should read it first so they know what they're getting into.
[1] http://pinyin.info/readings/texts/moser.html http://pinyin.info/readings/texts/moser.html
- PavlikPaja 8y agoThat's only true when you already speak English, or at least another Germanic or Romance language. Otherwise, all this applies to English exactly the same as it does to Chinese.
- crazygringo 8y agoNo, it's vastly easier for Chinese to learn English (or French or German) because they're generally phonetically-spelled languages. There aren't any cognates, but you don't spend years memorizing thousands and thousands of characters to learn English. And the payoff is much higher: learning Chinese only lets you communicate with Chinese/Taiwanese people. Learning English lets you communicate with a huge proportion of the world who also learns English as a second language, simply because it's the current lingua franca.
- namarie 8y ago> No, it's vastly easier for Chinese to learn English (or French or German) because they're generally phonetically-spelled languages. Interesting of you to make that claim as english spelling is usually a nightmare to learn (as is French spelling to a minor extent). Sometimes people really are learning it word by word. It seems easier for you because you're already familiar with it. > And the payoff is much higher: learning Chinese only lets you communicate with Chinese/Taiwanese people. Learning English lets you communicate with a huge proportion of the world who also learns English as a second language, simply because it's the current lingua franca. Well, seeing as there are well over a billion of chinese people I'd think twice about using the word "only". Also there are many who speak it as a second language as well.
- bgee 8y ago> but you don't spend years memorizing thousands and thousands of characters to learn English except you are memorizing thousands and thousands of spellings to learn English
- yakshaving_jgt 8y agoThis sounds like BS to me. There are rules and exceptions to those rules one must learn/memorise, but I highly doubt it's "thousands and thousands". There's a lot of English comprehension you get "for free" by knowing some of these rules, e.g., "magic e" or [the actually incorrect] "i before e, except after c".
- bgee 8y ago> There are rules and exceptions to those rules one must learn/memorise, but I highly doubt it's "thousands and thousands". Exactly my point: This is true in Chinese (Hanzi) as well. Edit: English-speaking individuals often overestimate the difficulty of learning Hanzi while underestimate the barrier of learning English spelling. For an example, see Ted Chiang's claim of "you need only learn a few dozen symbols and you can read most everything printed in a newspaper" [0]. [0]: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/05/16/if-chinese-were-phonetic https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/05/16/if-chinese-wer...
- qiqing 8y agoTo this day, English is difficult for my parents, who have a hard time keeping gendered pronouns straight. But at least the irregularity of the numerical system isn't as weird as French. Chinese is considerably easier and English considerably harder if your first language is an Asian language.
- clairity 8y ago> “...have a hard time keeping gendered pronouns straight.” ha, i see that in the english captioning sometimes when watching chinese dramas. at least gender is only in the pronouns, rather than (nearly) every word via gender suffixes (like the romance languages).
- FabHK 8y agoHow can they write Chinese if they can't get gendered pronouns straight? (他 vs. 她) Chinese numbers quite logical and straightforward, true, though French (and German etc.) numbers pose small hurdles only, I'd say. > Chinese is considerably easier and English considerably harder if your first language is an Asian language. That really depends which language you're talking about. I'd bet most Indonesians, for example, would disagree. However, granted, a language will be easier when you are familiar with a language that has many cognates.
- qiqing 8y ago他 vs. 她 was invented in order to maintain compatibility with Western languages, and using 他 in place of 她 is not considered grammatically incorrect, and you don't learn to write both of them until you start to read and write in school, not when you're a baby learning to talk. For instance, when my birth certificate was translated into English, there are male pronouns littered everywhere because the inexperienced translator didn't give it a second thought, even though the gender field was clearly marked as female. French, though is particularly brutal for Chinese native speakers, because not only do you have to consciously track each human speaker's gender and whether they are in groups of mixed males and females or all females, but also track the arbitrary genders of objects.
- WilliamEdward 8y agoBut do you believe it's the same for young students who have tons of free time over the space of many years? I'm not sure your personal experience dictates an absolute about this situation. I was forced to learn an extremely niche language in school; even learning the basics of chinese would have been more useful.
- crazygringo 8y agoI do. There's actually a very plausible theory that Chinese economic development is harmed by the sheer number of hours schoolchildren spend memorizing characters rather than conceptual learning -- that moving to a phonetic alphabet would be a huge boost in terms of overall learning. (This isn't a Western argument, it's a Chinese argument for phoneticization which is still mostly opposed by the population.) Young students don't have "tons of free time" -- their school time is spent on something, and if they're memorizing Chinese characters, then there are necessarily other skills that will be less developed.
- chillacy 8y agoMost of those arguments were made when China was 3rd world, it’ll get harder to sell that each passing year. Also that’s a great argument to simplify English as well, but few seem thrilled about that idea.