5 ms·
I wrote my dissertation in Word. 200+ pages, dozens of captioned and numbered figures and tables, over 100 equations all numbered and referenced, table of conte
by ModernMech 8y ago
I wrote my dissertation in Word. 200+ pages, dozens of captioned and numbered figures and tables, over 100 equations all numbered and referenced, table of contents, cross references, works cited. I found it quite pleasant.
- paultopia 8y agoI wrote a book in Word. It was a nightmare, but a useful one: a version conflict across users or something in the copyediting phase glitch-deleted all the math from a chapter ... but in laboriously reconstructing them I found and fixed an error in the original. So thanks Microsoft?
- _emacsomancer_ 8y agoI'm glad it worked out for you. I would have gone mad if I'd tried to write my dissertation in Word. (As it is, I'm, nearly a decade later, still a bit touched after trying to do much minor work involving lambda calculus in Word.)
- megous 8y agoOn my old 486, I wrote about 80 page document about signal processing in Word, full of painstakingly created equations, until one day, all equations basically disappeared or became uneditable. I learned my lesson there about wysiwyg.
- ModernMech 8y agoThings have improved since 1989. Give it a shot again, you might be surprised!
- megous 8y ago1999 and it doesn't seem like, from other answers. The thing is that time invested in learning superior alternatives is already spent, and there's no point taking the risks just to try for no reason. Just like I will not create another website in FrontPage.
- kej 8y agoThey did completely overhaul the equation system in Office 2007 so that you edit them with unicode text instead of the proprietary OLE editor from previous versions. The document [1] describing how they use unicode characters to structure mathematical expressions is pretty interesting, even if you never touch MS Word again. [1] https://www.unicode.org/notes/tn28/UTN28-PlainTextMath.pdf https://www.unicode.org/notes/tn28/UTN28-PlainTextMath.pdf
- megous 8y agoThe compilable C++ snippet certainly looks interesting. It answers the question I always had, about why some languages added unicode identifiers. It doesn't look all that bad.
- com2kid 8y agoWord also supports LaTeX for equations! https://support.office.com/en-us/article/linear-format-equations-using-unicodemath-and-latex-in-word-2e00618d-b1fd-49d8-8cb4-8d17f25754f8 https://support.office.com/en-us/article/linear-format-equat...
- jon-wood 8y agoWord is fine if you really, really, know what you're doing with it. By that I mean understanding how to use styles for formatting, how to properly insert footnotes/figures/tables etc, and what the implications are if you don't. When my wife wrote her doctorate she did none of those things, and I ended up spending the best part of two days laboriously going through the entire document to make it conform to the university's style guide for thesis being submitted. Thankfully she uses Scrivener for writing now which as near as possible enforces doing things the right way the first time.
- ModernMech 8y ago> Word is fine if you really, really, know what you're doing with it. I would submit that the same is true for LaTeX.
- jandrese 8y agoMaybe the advantage of LaTeX is that people who don't know what they're doing will be scared off by the interface.
- da_chicken 8y agoYou mean that it will be perceived as so difficult to use that people will ignore it in favor of anything else? Calling that an advantage is a rather unique perspective. General document creation is not exactly something only a few specialists need to do.
- jandrese 8y agoI was a little tongue in cheek with that comment, but there could be a filter effect where people who aren't prepared to do it properly run away screaming from TeX and its many shells to the loving embrace of Microsoft Word, where they then do a terrible job and give Word a bad reputation. I've done plenty of work where the customer insists that the final deliverable be in Word format, because that's what they're comfortable with. You can do proper formatting in Word once you learn the tools, and it's not even all that hard, although it can be somewhat unforgiving of screwups. The one thing I wouldn't attempt is to convert a TeX document to Word. In theory that shouldn't be entirely possible, but in practice there are about a million ways it could blow up in your face.
- johan_larson 8y agoI wrote one thesis in LaTeX and one in Word. There were some challenges each way, but all in all, doing it in Word was easier. WYSIWYG helped a lot, Word had good documentation, and LaTeX was hard to customize to meet the university's formatting rules. I will admit, however, that LaTeX run on default settings looks good. Whoever designed that bit had taste.
- wbl 8y agoThe math department didn't have a package for that? I taught my middle school teacher latex so his quizes would look nicer.
- johan_larson 8y agoI don't remember being offered a package or template or anything like that. This was in 1995; I expect things have improved.
- chrisfinazzo 8y agoI first became aware of TeX generally when towards the end of writing my comp exam responses, I came across @kjhealy's templates. While this looked interesting, I didn't have the time to dive in (I was on deadline for revisions, and borrowing a family member's MacBook as the 8600M in my 15" died). With that said, I wonder if the people who actually did write a thesis/dissertation in LaTeX had to do all that customization themselves. For example, I'm in NJ and although I didn't go there, I could imagine Rutgers OIT telling people, 'If you want to use TeX, just download our package, it will install everything you need and will output the correct format for submission'
- hpcjoe 8y agoI wrote mine before word was really a thing. I used LaTex, and had to create my own style setup. It wasn't too difficult. I had programs generate EPS documents for inclusion of figures, resize jpg/png images, run the multiple pass latex compilation. I am pleased to report that the makefile for my thesis still works, and generates close to the original doc, 20 something years later. I can barely open a 10+ year old office doc thanks to incompatibilities within the product. Back in those days, word processors would not do complicated multi-line equations very well; type setting for print, display, etc. This was a problem for me. To each their own though. I wound up writing some user manuals for products I developed in the late 90's in LaTeX as well. I've not used it much since.
- mcguire 8y agoTrue story: E. Allen Emerson once came knocking at the unix cave door, complaining that his older papers, written in LaTeX, were formatting differently. Upon examination, the only difference, literally, was that we had replaced the ancient 300dpi printers with less ancient 600dpi printers. And yes, CMR is a spindley little font.