4 ms·
re “I conclude that while self-labeled Austrian economists have some valid contributions to make to economics, these are simply not distinctive enough to sustai
by mark_l_watson 8y ago
re “I conclude that while self-labeled Austrian economists have some valid contributions to make to economics, these are simply not distinctive enough to sustain a school of thought“
This seems a little crazy to me. I think there is a world of difference between current economic philosophy that runs the US-centered world and Austrian Economics as depicted on the Mises web site.
I am not an economist but I do sometimes read the Mises.org web site and until recently I made monthly contributions to support the site.
I credit Mises.org with information that led me to divest my retirement accounts out of the stock market in 1997. That saved me a lot of money.
- simias 8y agoI'm not sure I understand your argument, the Mises Institute could make valid contributions to the field of economics without being a distinctive school of thought. I mean the paragraph you've quoted says exactly as much, in full: >I conclude that while self-labeled Austrian economists have some valid contributions to make to economics, these are simply not distinctive enough to sustain a school of thought. The task of developing an alternate Austrian paradigm has largely failed, producing an abundance of meta-economics (philosophy, methodology, and history of thought), but few substantive results. Whatever Austrian economists have that is worth saying should be simply be addressed to the broader economics profession, which (in spite of itself) remains eager for original, true, and substantive ideas. He doesn't say that Austrian economists are always wrong, he says that even when they're right their works do not justify a completely different economic paradigm. The fact that anecdotally you saved some money by following their advice doesn't really contradict that IMO.
- jplayer01 8y agoI don't even see how he saved money. If he'd stayed in the market, he would've made tons of returns by now. It's more like he avoided short-term loss and long-term profit. Unless for some reason he was invested in companies like stufffordogs.com.
- mark_l_watson 8y agoI waited a few years and returned to investing in the stock market.