3 ms·
You can only win as a "gig economy" as long as you find a weak spot (a.k.a loophole) in regulations and use it. That loophole will close, and the business will
by alkonaut 8y ago
You can only win as a "gig economy" as long as you find a weak spot (a.k.a loophole) in regulations and use it. That loophole will close, and the business will either need to expand or converge to a traditional business of the kind it displaced. AirBnB will be like any other apartment rental place. Uber will be (and is already in many places) like any other Taxi company. It should be called the "loophole upstart economy". What they do is grow at a breakneck sped into an area where there is regulation that can be abused. The trick is to grow so fast that regulation can't keep up (in the US you can even grow so fast that eventually you'll be big enough to lobby your own regulation).
As an example:
In Stockholm where there are no Taxi mediallions (anyone can be a taxi or car hire service in any way they want as long as they regiser and comply with insurance, standardized meters, and other regulations) and the competition alreay has new cars, app-based booking etc - there is precious little margin for Uber to cut from, compared to a city with medallions, cab shortages, ancient taxi companies that don't offer app hauling/prepayment etc.
So how can Uber make a killing in Stockholm? Answer: they find another regulation to work around. Tax regulation. Taxis are required to enter all fares into the meter and that's reported to tax authorities. Uber drivers are supposed to enter the rides themselves into the meter after completing. The kicker is: there is a huge incentive for the individual driver to under-report the fares, and that incentive also helps Uber. This being revealed will obviously now mean that Uber will be forced to pay an estimated and much higher tax, and the drivers won't be trusted to do this themselves in the fuuture. And this will only mean one thing: Uber will pack up and leave. There is no way they can be competitive (to the extent their investors will want) without breaking either Tax law or Labor laws.
- Jommi 8y agoHow do you know this much about the market?
- alkonaut 8y agoAbout the Stockholm Taxi market? I live there and follow local news, and have some interest in the area, that's it. Regular taxi drivers aren't paid that much and those companies offer everything Uber offers: app haul/pay, nice cars and so on, so if Uber don't have an edge anywhere either legally, technologically or economically (e.g use contractors instead of employees, be the only one to offer nice apps, have greater scale scale, adaptive pricing) then they aren't going to make a large margin. I might be wrong though but this is my guess. Companies that have good margins without tax fraud tend to not do tax fraud.
- Jommi 8y agoDon't you have to pay high startup costs to be a driver in stockholm? As far as I know it's a completely different setup with Taxi companies and their hired drivers that work on comission, compared to Uber that works with private contractors. Do you need a company to start earning money as a cab driver?
- alkonaut 8y agoStartup costs depends on what way you do it. Own company would be most expensive but a regular taxi driver just works for one of the big taxi companies and owns their car or shares it with someone to het higher utilization. Simplest and cheapest with least risk (and least profit) would be working for an established company using a car owned by someone else. Note that in Stockholm Uber is a regular licensed taxi company. Any taxi company can operate like Uber and vice versa.
- Jommi 8y agoSo all someone needs to drive in Sweden is this Taxi Driver license? Then they can just jump in their car and start earning?
- alkonaut 8y agoYes. It's a driver job like any other (bus license for bus, taxi license for taxi, truck license for trucks...). Most companies probably have cars unused at times. E.g. if you are a student and want to make some extra money it's usually easy to get a weekend job using someone elses car when that driver is off anyway. That way you can make some money without a big investment in a car.
- Jommi 8y agoso you can't just drive your own car? That's exactly what Uber is about.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoUber is a better example. Airbnb is a different case in my view. Vacation rentals have been around for forever, and they were pretty terrible before Airbnb. When I used VRBO back in 2006 or so, it wasn’t horrible but wasn’t amazing. And the market was fragmented and inefficient. Airbnb basically made it so easy to both rent out space and rent space from others that it grew the market very dramatically in a short period of time. So much so that it exposed a lot of problems that weren’t present before with a few hard-to-book vacation rentals here and there.
- alkonaut 8y agoYes, the difference I think is that AirBnB has grown so big it actually changed neighborhoods and accomodation markets in a way we didn't see before. The question becomes the same as for Uber in some sense: once a single company professionally rents out all the flats in a highrise building, what makes them different from a hotel and why do they get to dodge expensive regulations and inspections that hotels need? Their business model is being an apartment hotel and not admitting it.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoBut again, Airbnb doesn’t own or rent those units, or choose to put them on the market. Should they only allow a certain percentage of units in a particular building or neighborhood to be rented out? How is that fair to marginal apartment owner who also wants to rent their space out? I think Airbnb could do a better job of working with cities to ensure that negative externalities don’t poison the well. But I don’t hold them responsible for the tsunami of demand on both sides of this market. It seems pretty clear that people really, really want this, and I don’t think the right answer is “too bad, stay in an overpriced chain hotel”
- alkonaut 8y agoAirBnB rents those units out if they have a nontrivial gain from it. That they merely provide the service doesn’t seem important. Same with Uber - doesn’t matter who owns th cars or whether they claim to not employ anyone. They are a large taxi operator and the drivers should have employee benefits (as was ruled in many places already).
- Erwin 8y agoAfter Uber exited the Danish market, the Danish tax authority received details (from the Dutch tax authorities) of whom Uber actually paid. It turned out 99% of the drivers did not put that income on their electronic tax forms. Uber's statement was that the individual drivers are responsible for that sort of thing. Wink, wink. What's worse 75% of them were receiving various types of government money for unemployed people (which are supposed to be decreased if are able to find a job). Uber is planning to return to the Danish market -- the Danish spokesperson says they will return "with integrity". AirBnb however has agreed to automated reporting of who receives rental income in Denmark. If you agree to automatic reporting as a landlord, you get a certain tax discount.
- Jommi 8y agoWould love to get a source on that 99% figure!
- ninju 8y agohttps://www.reuters.com/article/us-uber-denmark-tax/denmark-hits-1200-former-uber-drivers-with-additional-tax-idUSKCN1HB0YC https://www.reuters.com/article/us-uber-denmark-tax/denmark-... The new checks were based on information Denmark had received from the Dutch authorities, where Uber’s European headquarter is based. Danish tax authorities said in a statement they had checked 1,195 Uber drivers’ tax reports and of those 1,192 have had their tax changed now.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoWhy is it Uber’s responsibility though? Why is this different from how restaurant servers are required to report their cash tips, but basically none of them do? Should we blame the servers, the restaurant owner, the government, all of them, no one?
- thatoneuser 8y agoThat industry shouldn’t exist the way it does either imho. It’s wrought with tax evasion itself. And minimum wage needs to be respected.