4 ms·
For people interested in learning more about the author's (Bryan Caplan) background and views: http://thepolitic.org/an-interview-with-bryan-caplan-professor-o
by freedomben 8y ago
For people interested in learning more about the author's (Bryan Caplan) background and views: http://thepolitic.org/an-interview-with-bryan-caplan-professor-of-economics-at-george-mason-university/ http://thepolitic.org/an-interview-with-bryan-caplan-profess...
- thedailymail 8y agoI don't agree with Prof Caplan on a lot of things but generallly respect his intellect. But I was very surprised and disappointed to read his views here on alcoholism being a matter of choosing "a beverage over one's family" rather than a legitimate medical issue.
- hopler 8y agoMany people who are experts in one field like economics assume they are experts in all fields including medicine.
- megous 8y agoThat's not it. It's more like the belief that economics and psychology are separate and economic theory should restrict itself to dealing with expressed preferences, and not be concerned with how those preferences came to be.
- fingerlocks 8y agoI believe the professor is discussing the implications of choosing A over B, not examining why the choice was made.
- thedailymail 8y agoBut that is the point. Most addiction experts don't describe alcohol dependence in terms of choice, but as a physical addiction.
- throwaway98121 8y agoHe completely lost me here. >Of course, if the problem is just inequality, then that’s one case where I would say there’s all sorts of inequality, so why is that actually something that is so bad the government needs to do something about it? Again, it’s different if you have people starving to death versus not being happy that they’re getting paid 5 percent less than what they ought to be getting paid. Okay so because there is inequality and some dimensions are worse than other, government shouldn’t do anything about anything. And if you’re not a privileged elite male who was educated, that’s just too bad because you are not the only one. The government should just leave everyone alone, and if some people are discriminated against, then his study on incomes of black males is enough to refute any kind of inequality in the workplace (or anywhere else for that matter). I’m trying to paraphrase what I understood. How does anyone, regardless of their political biases, respect this guy or his “intellect”? I know I sound harsh, but please enlighten me. For the record, I’m socially liberal but fiscally conservative.
- civilian 8y agoLife is unfair. Although you may not know it, there's a good chance that you are not the equally favorite child of your parents. We are all given different talents, and it would be impossible for the government to level the playing field. I'm shorter than the average American man. Unfair!! I have a stutter. Unfair!! My brother runs faster than I do, Unfair! I waste time writing comments on internet forums. Unfair! The guvm'nt outta do something to prevent all this inequality! (You might read http://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html http://www.tnellen.com/cybereng/harrison.html )