5 ms·
You seem a bit disingenuous here. Upthread you needed "a source" for the obvious fact that hospitals are part of a national economy. Now the deaths of children
by jessaustin 8y ago
You seem a bit disingenuous here. Upthread you needed "a source" for the obvious fact that hospitals are part of a national economy. Now the deaths of children are "a natural result". Which is it, really? Maybe it's just good for USA policy to kill kids, by one way or another? Anyway, sanctions are usually just a pretext for war. (Every military disaster USA has perpetrated during my parents' lifetimes has been preceded by sanctions.) The military-industrial-media complex tells us over and over that sanctions are some sort of peaceful option, but a cursory examination of history proves that is a damnable lie.
"The alternative" is what every president from Washington through Arthur would have advocated: stay on our own continent and mind our own business.
- dunpeal 8y ago> Upthread you needed "a source" for the obvious fact that hospitals are part of a national economy. No, I asked for a source for the claim that the US blocked essential medical supplies as part of the embargo. > "The alternative" is what every president from Washington through Arthur would have advocated: stay on our own continent and mind our own business. Wouldn't mind that at all! However, since I don't make these decisions, then I will persist: sanctions are better than the violent killing of war.
- jessaustin 8y agoWe voters don't make either decision; our rulers in the military-industrial-media complex decide when to drag us into war. It's still the case that sanctions are usually just pretexts for war. If sanctions themselves were neutral policies, that might be acceptable. However as documented upthread they kill lots of innocent children directly. Most humans would consider that to be a bad thing.
- dunpeal 8y agoSanctions are often an attempt to curb aggression and prevent war. Take the sanctions against Russia or Iran. Sure, we can be against those sanctions. Then Russia will invade the rest of Ukraine, killing many thousands. It's the easiest thing in the world to say "I'm just against any sort of killing". Makes you seem benevolent. However, in reality we must choose between alternatives that are often all bad, some just a bit more so.
- jessaustin 8y agoYou keep repeating that (probably because you've heard it repeated a lot), but it isn't true. Sanctions at most times and in most places have been pretexts for future wars. Sanctions are certainly not what have kept Russia from invading Ukraine: Ukrainians with guns and tanks have done that. Sanctions certainly have not caused Russia to give back the Crimea to Ukraine. It's like any disputed territory inhabited by mostly-sane people. The residents who wanted Russian rule are happy, many of those who didn't have moved back to Ukraine, and it's not as though any of the civic institutions really work differently anyway. I am not "against any sort of killing". If I have a good enough reason to kill I will do it. I have killed lots of animals while hunting and dealing with livestock. I am not "benevolent". However, I am also not evil. It is for that reason that I don't want my tax dollars used to kill innocent children in foreign lands. The killing done by Assad, Qaddafi, Saddam, and the Taliban is on their own heads. (The killing done by ISIS is on ours, because we created and sustained ISIS.) In my parents' lifetimes, we have never improved a situation overseas by invading. By that measure I suppose sanctions are a little better, because it's arguable that e.g. South Africa was improved by sanctions...
- dunpeal 8y ago> Sanctions are certainly not what have kept Russia from invading Ukraine: Ukrainians with guns and tanks have done that. The Russians have a ton more guns and tanks. Like it or not, Russians don't invade Ukraine because of repercussions, and sanctions are part of that. If we were back in 1940, the Russians would have taken over Ukraine long ago. > (The killing done by ISIS is on ours, because we created and sustained ISIS.) Conspiracy theory.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Like it or not, Russians don't invade Ukraine Yes, like it or not, they do. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_military_intervention_in_Ukraine_(2014–present) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_military_interventio...
- jessaustin 8y ago