5 ms·
The DMCA protection against false claims are woefully inadequate to the point of being non-existant.
by gumby 8y ago
The DMCA protection against false claims are woefully inadequate to the point of being non-existant.
- Waterluvian 8y agoWhat's the practical mechanism that stops official videos like trailers from being DMCA'd every time one is uploaded?
- gumby 8y agoWell if they're uploaded by the copyright holder they're unlikely to be DMCAed (though it happens :-). And why should they protest a trailer -- it's an ad for their film, right? But these shortsighted folks often will DMCA one. In theory you can be liable for damages for filing a false DMCA claim (a couple of examples here: http://www.aaronkellylaw.com/consequences-of-filing-a-false-dmca-takedown-request/ http://www.aaronkellylaw.com/consequences-of-filing-a-false-... ). In practice it almost never happens, which surprises me as they are a nuisance for the YTs of the world who have to handle the complaints.
- stanmancan 8y agoPeople get copystrikes on YouTube all the time for ridiculous reasons. Playing a cover of a song? Copystrike. Humming 3 seconds of the halo theme song? Copystrike. Playing a song on a paper towel dispenser in a public bathroom? https://youtu.be/Tqj2csl933Q https://youtu.be/Tqj2csl933Q
- Waterluvian 8y agoI mean what's stopping malicious people from trying to fight fire with fire by incorrectly claiming all the movie and music industry's legitimate stuff? Does YouTube give them special status?
- Khaine 8y agoExcept they are not using the DMCA, they are using google's own content id process, which has no checks and/or balances[1]. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2013/12/19/the-injustice-of-the-youtube-content-id-crackdown-reveals-googles-dark-side/#3b78c46c66c8 https://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2013/12/19/the-injus...
- Buge 8y agoI thought Content ID just referred to the automated content recognition system, not to manually claimed things. That article you linked to seems to agree. So the video in this post seems to be primarily not about Content ID.
- polishTar 8y agoNot exactly true. The YT claim system is optional. Either party can bypass it and force it through the DMCA/other legal process if they want (the claimee can do this by filing a dispute+appeal). Of course doing this opens the claimee to potentially far more dire consequences if the claimant chooses to for example file a lawsuit against the claimee, which is why disputing+appealing can be dangerous and most creators aren't willing to do it (or they might just dispute but choose not to follow a rejected dispute with an appeal). The benefit of the YT claim system is that 1) it usually gives a good enough remedy to copyright holders such that they won't feel the need to file DMCA takedowns or lawsuits against creators 2) it isn't subject to the DMCA's repeat infringement requirement (which manifests itself on YT and most other platforms as a 3-strikes-your-out policy) 3) it offers far more granular remedies (a claim won't always result in the video being taken down for instance) and 4) it's optional! If a claimee is willing to defend their content against a DMCA takedown or in court if need be, then they can always dispute+appeal On the other hand, one of the big disadvantages of the claim system is that it makes navigating YT copyright confusing as hell to those unfamiliar with it. The misinformation that's so prevalent on the claim system just makes everything so much worse. Not entirely sure how YT could improve that TBH.
- 6nf 8y ago> Either party can bypass it and force it through the DMCA process if they want That's not true as far as I can tell. If my video gets claimed there's nowhere in the Youtube UI that allows me to do this? If this is really an option could you show me how to do this please? From what I can tell my only real option is to 'dispute' and then the supposed 'rightsholder' just says 'nope' and my dispute goes away with no further recourse.
- 8y ago