3 ms·
FWIW: Pathfinder didn't win because it didn't have the name. The game itself is fine. But there can be only one D&D, and once WotC managed to figure out that
by ajross 8y ago
FWIW: Pathfinder didn't win because it didn't have the name. The game itself is fine. But there can be only one D&D, and once WotC managed to figure out that the edition upgrade mill was a death trap and released a streamlined 5e, there wasn't much niche left for Pathfinder to fill.
Given a "Pathfinder" vs. "D&D" choice, and no overwhelming community consensus either way (the community rejection of the fourth edition is the reason Pathfinder exists as a commercial product at all), everyone's going to buy the game with the famous name.
- toyg 8y ago> Pathfinder didn't win because it didn't have the name. And the history. '80s nostalgia is a big thing right now, and D&D can drink at that well. Quite a lot of people who made it in Hollywood and are powerful right now, were D&D players 30 years ago when they were kids; so they supplied the glam factor that helps keeping games out of the "nerd" niche.
- p1necone 8y agoI wonder if Stranger Things featuring DnD made a significant impact.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> FWIW: Pathfinder didn't win because it didn't have the name. The game itself is fine. But there can be only one D&D, and once WotC managed to figure out that the edition upgrade mill was a death trap and released a streamlined 5e, there wasn't much niche left for Pathfinder to fill. 5e was the second D&D edition released after Pathfinder, so I'm not really sure what “edition upgrade mill” you are talking about. > (the community rejection of the fourth edition is the reason Pathfinder exists as a commercial product at all), Pathfinder was released to wide acclaim before 4e; it's true that with sufficient acceptance 4e might still have displaced it, but the real reason for PF was the announced imminent replacement of the 3e Open Game License with a more restrictive Game System License for the upcoming 4e, and what that said for both Paizo (who made Pathfinder) and other third-party players in the 3e/3.5e ecosystem. It's perhaps worth noting that 5e returned to an OGL core.
- ajross 8y agoOMG, we're actually having an edition war on HN! D&D really has broken through! Pathfinder beat 4e to market in a technical sense, but it absolutely exists because WotC announced it was moving away from 3.5e and the OGL with a new edition. Paizo never intended to release it to compete directly with 3.5, and it would have been insane to do so.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 8y ago> OMG, we're actually having an edition war on HN! D&D really has broken through! Are we? The disagreements seem to be about details of why various editions succeeded or failed, not about their superiority.
- 2muchcoffeeman 8y agoWell, we expect HN to have a slightly higher level of discourse right? :)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoPathfinder's entire market was "people who didn't like 4E and wanted to keep playing [/selling OGL supplements for] for 3.5," and on that basis they were one of the only games to come close to matching D&D's success. (They may actually have outside D&D for a few years; it's hard to be sure because WotC doesn't release those numbers.) It was only 4E's divisiveness that let them find a niche, and they started slipping as soon as WotC released a new edition that fixed most of the things that pissed people off about 4E.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoPathfinder does have a pretty large following. They also have a new Pathfinder 2.0 coming soon.