3 ms·
I'd agree with the general point of the article. There seems to be a sort of self-styled counter-culture movement emerging around sites like Quillette and it's
by Barrin92 8y ago
I'd agree with the general point of the article. There seems to be a sort of self-styled counter-culture movement emerging around sites like Quillette and it's basically a very clever branding because it sells. Like the author I haven't found anything great or original on the website, what sets its apart is its opposition to the 'mainstream media'.
When I see this debate I just have to think of Kissinger's remark on academic discourse: "Academic politics are so vicious because the stakes are so small".
I have serious trouble believing for a second that a group of liberal college professors, affluent middle-class inhabitants and million follower podcasts hosts is somehow seriously ostracised.
This has always existed and these back and forth knife fights about who has the right to speak with authority in small intellectual or academic circles is as old as history. What concerns me a little is to what degree people capitalise on this both financially (on say Patreon) or culturally by declaring the decline of Western civilisation, and how it is seeping into mainstream, who would in my opinion be better off ignoring all of it.
- deogeo 8y agoPopularity/affluence and being ostracized aren't mutually exclusive: https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/05/23/can-things-be-both-popular-and-silenced/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/05/23/can-things-be-both-pop...
- Barrin92 8y agoThis isn't a good faith comparison. (as the article itself seems to indicate at one point). Transgender people or early 20th century union organisers faced the threat of physical violence or legal discrimination. Sam Harris (or someone in a comparable spot) does not face legal discrimination or state violence. He just faces public and intellectual backlash. And that's perfectly okay. If you're a radical LGBT activist you're likely not welcome in a conservative church. What do lgbt activists do? They don't go there. As a labour activist I'm not welcome at the local Ayn Rand memorial. What do I do? I don't go there. It's a fact of free association that nobody is going to be welcome everywhere 100% of the time. The problem here isn't actual discrimination. It's that Pinker et al imagine themselves to be Enlightenment era Voltaires who preach wisdom to the masses who don't know any better, and mistake private controversy or at worst a middle finger for discrimination. In short, they're not popular and ostracised in the way labour rights were historically, they're popular and ostracised in the way a modern day televangelist is.
- deogeo 8y agoFor every person in a comparable spot to Sam Harris, there are many who keep their mouth shut for fear of losing their job. But it's not violence or discrimination by the law, so not only is it OK, but they shouldn't even complain about it.