3 ms·
Because when the loan is forgiven after 20 years it looks like income. So you have to pay tax on your forgiven loan. If Lambda School can’t teach you well enoug
by gigatexal 8y ago
Because when the loan is forgiven after 20 years it looks like income. So you have to pay tax on your forgiven loan. If Lambda School can’t teach you well enough that you get and keep a good paying job then they take the loss not the tax payer.
Also: advocating for keeping the old system by saying this new way is not different is the least Hacker News things I’ve ever heard. The student loan crisis is an existential crisis for America. More schools should adopt the Lambda School approach, America would be much better off.
The current model is no different to unscrupulous bankers selling loans to Wall Street or Fannie Mae: they just lure students to the school helping them fill out student aid and loans and then give them subpar educations with curriculum being taught like it has been for years but they don’t care to change or innovate because the school has already been paid by an entity — the US education department who has deep pockets.
- ChrisLomont 8y ago>they just lure students to the school helping them fill out student aid and loans and then give them subpar educations with curriculum being taught like it has been for years but they don’t care to change or innovate because the school has already been paid by an entity — the US education department who has deep pockets. Total tuition loans outstanding is around $1.5T. Total US Education Dept annual budget, 70B. Median length to pay off student loans is around 20 years. 30% of people graduate with no debt, and of the remaining, median debt is around $30k, the cost of a decent car, and a fraction of what the same people will pay for a house. Adding the entire Ed budget for the past 20 years is no where near the amount of loans outstanding. And in fact they lend only a fraction of their budget to student tuition. Thus your claim that the US Ed dept is paying at the end of the day is mathematically impossible. The debt is from private lenders, who do have incentive to ensure borrowers pay back.
- gigatexal 8y agoLoans are a mix of subsidized and unsubsidized, sure. But the issue is that the incentive is that of any loan owner: repayment of the loan. With Lambda School the incentive is making better, more employable, engineers and the loans will pay themselves off. What good does it do the person and the economy if a bunch of people are straddled with debt for 30 years for a degree they can’t use being hounded by creditors while the universities remain the same? In the end there’s a network of entities that all own debt that will never get paid back, debt that is for all intents and purposes subprime. Remind you of anything?
- nateabele 8y ago> The debt is from private lenders, who do have incentive to ensure borrowers pay back. Not necessarily. Private banks issuing federally-backed student loans want you to default, because then they double their money. See here: http://www.collegescholarships.org/research/student-loans/ http://www.collegescholarships.org/research/student-loans/
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoYour link doesn’t show how a defaulted loan is more valuable to a private bank than a performing loan. It would be more accurate to say private banks are relatively indifferent to the performance of a loan. (They’re actually marginally incentivised to collect performing loans, since that is a cross-selling opportunity.)
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Private banks issuing federally-backed student loans Don't exist. They used to, before 2010, though (the propagadagraphic you link obliquely alludes to that with it's reference to the “Obama changes” that it does not explain, perhaps because they render the flowchart entirely irrelevant.)
- rayiner 8y agoThe DOE budget doesn’t include disbursed student loans. These days, the DOe disburses over $120 billion in loans per year. Almost all student debt ($1.33 trillion of $1.5 trillion) is Federal government issued.
- ChrisLomont 8y agoDo you have a source? Every one I find states the numbers I posted above, no where near your number. Total federal and non federal combined is currently around $100B annual.
- rayiner 8y agoI guess my number is a bit dated. It's $95 billion in federal loans in the most recent year, but it peaked at $117 billion in 2010-2011. https://trends.collegeboard.org/sites/default/files/2017-trends-student-aid_0.pdf https://trends.collegeboard.org/sites/default/files/2017-tre... page 9. Still, the DOE budget cannot reflect that since it is much less. Non-federal loans account for 11% of loans: https://trends.collegeboard.org/student-aid/figures-tables/total-federal-and-nonfederal-loans-over-time https://trends.collegeboard.org/student-aid/figures-tables/t....
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoIt doesn't just _look_ like income. It is income. If I give you $100 as a loan then change my mind and say 'you can have it', you just made $100.
- TheRealPomax 8y agoWhat if we turn it into something a little more analogous, and I loan you $100, and you use that $100, and I never asked for it back, but 12 years later go "actually you know what, never mind about paying me back", that's not $100 you now have. That's $100 you had 12 years ago. But we also need to make sure to keep the analogy in the same ball park, not the same county, so when we're talking $100, the tax on that isn't going to bankrupt you and it's a bad analogy. Let's up that by a factor of 500 instead: when we're talking a full student loan, if I say "actually, keep it", I literally just bankrupted you for kicks, and you should have had some kind of legal protection that prevented me from ruining your life on a whim.
- thedufer 8y agoThat can't be right. You're saying that going from $50k in debt to a student loan lender to $12k or so in debt to the IRS is a bad thing? Why do you care so much about who owns your debt that cutting it by 3/4 is a loss? Not only that, but now your debt can be eliminated in bankruptcy (a unique feature of student loans is that they are immune to bankruptcy). This looks like an altogether enormous win.
- gigatexal 8y agoI don’t care about who owns it. But paying income taxes on 50k of forgiven debt would be hard for me.
- thedufer 8y agoSure, it might be hard. But my point is that it can't be harder than paying the debt itself. Debt forgiveness does not leave you in a worse position unless your marginal tax rate is more than 100%, which is vanishingly rare.