4 ms·
The world is a better [0] place if less people have nuclear weapons. "Outlawing business" (i.e. sanctions) are being used to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear
by gpm 8y ago
The world is a better [0] place if less people have nuclear weapons. "Outlawing business" (i.e. sanctions) are being used to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons. Thus it improves the world [1].
[0] Better is somewhat subjective I suppose, but I think we can pretty objectively say "more likely to hold a human civilization 100 years from now".
[1] It also undoubtedly makes the world worse in other ways, whether it improves the world more than it makes it worse is too political for me to be interested in discussing it with strangers on the internet.
- koube 8y agoThere's an easier way to do it that required no effort on the part of the current administration, which is to just not cancel the Iran deal. > By torpedoing U.S. adherence to the accord, Trump has all but guaranteed its collapse, a move that opens the door to the unfettered resumption of Iran’s nuclear program and unleashes unpredictable escalatory pressures in an already volatile Middle East. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2018/05/08/around-the-halls-brookings-experts-discuss-the-implications-of-president-trumps-iran-nuclear-deal-announcement/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2018/05/08/a... > Although the deal didn’t address every concern, it was successfully preventing Iran from developing a nuclear weapon. Trump has instead opted for an uncertain future, raising the risks of an Iranian bomb and a U.S-Iranian conflict. https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/trumps-iran-deal-withdrawal-sets-needless-international-crisis https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/trumps-iran-dea... > The United States is left without good options moving forward. It is hard to see how this decision serves U.S. interests or regional stability. https://www.rand.org/blog/2018/05/the-strategic-fallout-of-us-withdrawal-from-the-iran.html https://www.rand.org/blog/2018/05/the-strategic-fallout-of-u... In addition I believe there are long term costs for a country to be violating agreements for no discernible benefit.
- rgbrenner 8y agoThe deal with Iran is not relevant.. since Huewai's and Meng's actions are from 5+ years ago, when Iran was subject to UN approved sanctions.
- koube 8y agoYou're correct, although I would say the Iran deal is still relevant to Iran sanctions in the general sense.
- austinheap 8y agoWhile I agree exiting the Iran deal was a mistake, your links are pretty one-sided... 1) The Brookings Institute is a right-wing pay-to-play lobbying group: https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Brookings_Institution https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Brookings_Institution 2) Cato Institute is funded by the Koch Brothers: https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Cato_Institute https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Cato_Institute 3) RAND Corp is partially funded by the US Govt: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAND_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAND_Corporation
- koube 8y agoBrookings and Rand are considered centrist, Rand sometimes center left, and Cato is conservative. I linked them because the case has already been made on the left, the case is usually being made to the right, so conservative sources would be relevant here.
- acali 8y agoThe quotes are by individuals associated with the organizations, it doesn't appear to be the official position of the think-tanks. I think it is unfair to call the Brookings Institute a "right-wing pay-to-play lobbying group" but you are just sourcing from a left-leaning activist group.
- austinheap 8y agoMy intention was to highlight the sources of funding for each -- not to make a pedantic left v right argument -- and people should question _all_ DC think tanks. Re: Brookings Institute, it's clear that their foreign sources of funding should cause pause: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brookings_Institution#Funding_controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brookings_Institution#Funding_...
- Udik 8y ago> "Outlawing business" (i.e. sanctions) are being used to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons. If you're talking about the current US sanctions, I think you're wrong. The deal ensured Iran could not develop nuclear weapons, through a strict regime of inspections. Without the deal, there are no inspections anymore and Iran is free to develop said weapons. It seems that the real purpose of the sanctions is to weaken Iran so that its enemies in the region (Israel, Saudi Arabia) have a freer hand in doing as they please.
- gpm 8y agoI'm talking about the sanctions that the article is, i.e. the pre-deal ones that Meng Wanzhou is accused of violating. That said, the stated reason for the current sanctions is still nuclear weapons [0]. An accurate evaluation of why the US chose to withdraw from that deal is probably not possible with publicly available information. The limited analysis in your comment seems to assume that the deal was effective, something I don't think we have enough information to reliably evaluate, but I consider unlikely. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/08/us/politics/trump-speech-iran-deal.html?action=click&module=inline&pgtype=Article https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/08/us/politics/trump-speech-...
- Udik 8y ago> That said, the stated reason for the current sanctions is still nuclear weapons Of course. And I think it's a blatant lie. > The limited analysis in your comment seems to assume that the deal was effective, something I don't think we have enough information to reliably evaluate The IAEA opinion is that we do, and that Iran has complied with the terms of the deal.
- gpm 8y agoThe IAEA opinion that I've seen is limited to "Iran has complied with the terms of the deal", not "the public has enough information to evaluate that the deal was effective at stopping nuclear weapons", or even "the deal is effective at stopping nuclear weapons development". The latter two (especially the middle one) being outside of the scope of what they discuss. It's possible I missed something, I would be surprised though since the IAEA is pretty tight lipped. To quote an IAEA statement [0] made a week before the US withdrew from the deal > In line with standard IAEA practice, the IAEA evaluates all safeguards-relevant information available to it. However, it is not the practice of the IAEA to publicly discuss issues related to any such information. [0] https://www.iaea.org/newscenter/pressreleases/statement-on-iran-by-the-iaea-spokesperson https://www.iaea.org/newscenter/pressreleases/statement-on-i...
- curiousgal 8y agoYup we can only achieve world peace if it's just us who owns nuclear weapons. If the goal is really that, the U.S. wouldn't be flashing its nuclear arsenal.
- tivert 8y agoThe more people there are who can choose to use nuclear weapons, the greater the chance that someone will actually choose to use them.
- berbec 8y agoCould the same argument apply to personal firearms?
- cronix 8y agoEspecially when one of the countries has vowed, time and time again, to wipe another country off the map.
- philbo 8y agoAdmittedly it's a very small sample size, but fwiw history directly contradicts this assertion.
- berbec 8y agoVery true. When only one nation had atomic weapons, 100% of the nations with nuclear capabilities utilized them.
- hevi_jos 8y agoThat will certainly be from a North American viewpoint. From the other countries perspective, it is a tremendous power imbalance. The fact that any city of your country could be destroyed by an invading force in 3 seconds at zero cost for the invaders is for sure not very reassuring. That actually happened in the US territory with native people, they were exterminated by outsiders with superior technology leaving almost not trace behind. This was costly for the invaders because the technology difference being great was not that great. Right now, with the US(spaceX) able to put a rocket in any part of the world in 30 minutes with a nuclear head, the power imbalance is extreme. They do not have to risk a single life to destroy an entire city or nation!! This is something that no country on earth should tolerate and they will not tolerate if if they have enough technology.