2 ms·
There's huge swathes of evidence. Read any decent economic history of the Soviet Union, or Maoist China. Or the analysis of the effect of handing power to worke
by simonh 8y ago
There's huge swathes of evidence. Read any decent economic history of the Soviet Union, or Maoist China. Or the analysis of the effect of handing power to workers councils in Yugoslavia, which I provided in answer to another such request. It was so common I even have family that watched it happen. My wife is Chinese, from Hohhot. Her father worked at a boiler factory and her mother at a textiles mill, both of which were run by worker councils and were badly mismanaged. They suffered appallingly under Maoism. This is one of the reasons this issue triggers me a bit.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> There's huge swathes of evidence. I'm still waiting to see any on point. > Read any decent economic history of the Soviet Union, or Maoist China. Which would be relevant if I was asking for evidence that Leninist vanguardism and it's derivatives were adequate systems to overcome the disadvantages poorly developed economies engaging in large scale geopolitical conflicts with advanced industrial powers face. Or if I was asking about evidence about the utility of top-down state central planning. But labor cooperatives don't require a state featuring Leninist vanguardism or top-down central planning, and in fact are a well-known practice in modern Western mixed economies like those in North America and Western Europe, and there are a lot of well-established observed differences between labor coops and classical capital-rents-labor firms within such systems, but I can't see any evidence that a higher failure rate for coops is one of them.
- simonh 8y agoRead my comment above again, referencing the example I cited across thread of the effects on the Yugoslav economy. I'll make it easier this time[0]. Yugoslavia is a perfect example actually because it wasn’t subject to Leninist Vanguardism, didn’t have the same competitive issues with the West, furthermore the worker councils weren’t subject to anywhere near as restrictive central planning constraints seen in most Marxist states, so it pretty much ticks all your boxes. Put it the way. What are the conditions in western democracies that are hostile to the success of workers cooperatives? We enjoy pretty egalitarian, fair legal and regulatory environments that aren't obviously hostile to them. Even if they were, many European countries have frequently had explicitly socialist governments and have had plenty of time to establish legal frameworks compatible with voluntary collectivism. Why hasn’t it worked? [0] https://capx.co/do-workers-need-capitalists-new-lessons-from-yugoslavias-socialist-experiment/ https://capx.co/do-workers-need-capitalists-new-lessons-from...