4 ms·
If the images in the article are at scale, the height of the rectangle is 1/8 of the width of the image, so if we assume that it is as width as posible with a s
by gus_massa 8y ago
If the images in the article are at scale, the height of the rectangle is 1/8 of the width of the image, so if we assume that it is as width as posible with a screen of ~1200 pixels, then the height of the rectangle is ~200 pixels.
Also, 1 degree = pi/180 ~=1/60 radians. The difference they are measuring is approximately 1/2 degree. So with a height of 200 the change of 1/2 degree is approximately 2 pixels. [In case it is not obvious, I'm making a lot of assumptions and approximation.]
The text explain the size of the groups: 175 (online), 25, 15, 15. [I'm not sure if this numbers are counted before or after eliminating the subjects that didn't understand the task.]
Looking at the graph my objection is that the three results where the "face" was looking at the rectangle are too consistent. They are .64±.23, .67±.30 and .63±.26. The difference in the three averages is only .04, but the standard deviation is like .25 in each case. And with 15 subjects you don't reduce the deviation of the average too much, so these values look fishy.
The other five results look more natural. The standard deviation is something like .20 or .30, and they are scattered randomly in a range of a similar width.
Are they reporting all the experiments they made, or they made a lot of experiments and cherrypicked four of them?
Also, in the graphic "The asterisk indicates D significantly greater than 0, P < 0.05." not that the two measurements have a difference that is statistically significantly. In particular in the third graph the error bars are too close to each other.