7 ms·
Until the people currently destroying forests to grow cattle, start destroying forests to grow ingredients for these burgers. Soil depletion is also a thing. I
by toyg 8y ago
Until the people currently destroying forests to grow cattle, start destroying forests to grow ingredients for these burgers. Soil depletion is also a thing. I still remember the argument for biofuel and where it ended up.
More options in the mix is always good, but trying to replace everything with vegetable stuff is not going to work in the long run.
- giarc 8y ago"but trying to replace everything with vegetable stuff is not going to work in the long run." But we have to eat... what do you recommend we replace our protein intake with?
- stochastic_monk 8y agoI suggest other plant protein sources, like soy or pea. Wheat, in particular, has a terrible amino acid profile for humans [0]. Aside from making it so that anyone with coeliac can't consume their burgers, it's just not as effective for humans as animal protein. Pea and soy, however, are nearly as effective and much better for the earth/environment. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3887888 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3887888
- nickik 8y agoThe Impossible Burger is designed to use environmentally friendly ingredients that can scale. I don't understand what your issue is.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoI’m suggesting they simply use different plant protein to do so. Would you consider wheat protein to be the only kind that can scale? If so, why?
- cpeterso 8y agoBeyond Meat, another meat-substitute company, uses soy and pea protein: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beyond_Meat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beyond_Meat
- Aromasin 8y agoQuinoa is also an excellent source for a full amino acid complex. It has substantially higher Lysine content then that found in other grains. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1546052 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1546052
- nate_meurer 8y agoThe incomplete protein thing is a myth [1]. The amino acid profile of single ingredients is almost never a concern in practice, because meals nearly always contain complimentary proteins. It's actually really difficult to avoid complimentary proteins if you have anything like normal dietary habits. Furthermore, it's not even necessary for every meal to provide all essential amino acids, as long as your diet isn't chronically deficient in any of them over time. Wheat protein is easy to complete. This is acknowledged at the link you gave: > when combined with other food proteins such as legumes, oil seeds or animal products the proteins of wheat exhibit excellent nutritional complementarity. Lysine is the limiting amino acid in wheat protein. Lysine is easy to find in other places, and wheat protein can be made fully complete using half as much pea protein, for example. A single 20 g portion of wheat protein similar in size to one impossible burger contains over a quarter of the RDA of lysine [2]. Nearly any other protein you consume in a day will easily provide the rest, even with sensible vegan diets. 1 - https://www.forksoverknives.com/the-myth-of-complementary-protein/ https://www.forksoverknives.com/the-myth-of-complementary-pr... 2 - https://www.nutritionvalue.org/Wheat_flour%2C_whole-grain_nutritional_value.html https://www.nutritionvalue.org/Wheat_flour%2C_whole-grain_nu...
- stochastic_monk 8y agoIt depends on your protein needs and goals. Survival is different from optimal performance.
- nate_meurer 8y agoNot sure what you mean by "optimal performance". Your body needs a finite daily amount of each essential amino acid for tissue growth and repair. If you're an athlete you might need more at times, and some health problems can cause usage of particular aminos to spike, but the requirement is always finite. Consuming more than those amounts has no proven benefit (unless that protein is meant to displace calories from carbs or fat, which is a completely different topic). Optimal daily intake of all essential amino acids is easy to achieve with any sensible dietary habit, even for very active adults. If you're consuming adequate protein each day, given your activity level and health, then the amino profile of your protein intake is completely irrelevant unless your diet is really goofy. I'd encourage you to read that Forks over Knives article.
- rebuilder 8y agoThe question you're replying to isn't the one being asked. Also, per the article, the current iteration of the Impossible Burger is no longer wheat-based.
- cerebellum42 8y agoThe cattle need to be fed too, and they don't turn their food into meat very efficiently. That's why replacing meat with plant based alternatives is (almost) always a huge gain in efficiency, in terms of resource use.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI believe this is an urban legend? Anyway, most crops don't convert to protein any better than cattle.
- cerebellum42 8y agoCrops are also not perfectly efficient, but it's simply replacing two chained instances of inefficiencies with one. Instead of Crops -> Animal feed -> Cattle -> Meat -> Eat you have Crops -> some processing -> Eat
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoThen there's the 92% of grazing land that doesn't grow crops. That's a clear win for cattle.
- yorwba 8y agoAccording to the UN's Food and Agriculture Organization [1] "just less than half the world's usable surface is covered by grazing systems" and "Grazing systems supply about 9 percent of the world's production of beef and about 30 percent of the world's production of sheep and goat meat." Doesn't seem like such a clear win for cattle. They do note that "For an estimated 100 million people in arid areas, and probably a similar number in other zones, grazing livestock is the only possible source of livelihood.", so not everyone might be able to afford a vegetarian diet, but 91% of beef seems replaceable. [1] http://www.fao.org/docrep/X5303E/x5303e05.htm#chapter%202:%20livestock%20grazing%20systems%20&%20the%20environment http://www.fao.org/docrep/X5303E/x5303e05.htm#chapter%202:%2...
- nate_meurer 8y ago
- rsynnott 8y agoGenerally, most of that forest destruction is to grow soy beans for animal feed. Feeding the soy beans directly to humans is far more efficient, so, if more people adopt TVP instead of meat, you'd expect a drop in land requirements.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoYou go ahead and spend your money on that stuff. But in a free market, soy-based protein is going to be a hard sell.
- yorwba 8y agoAccording to TFA, the Impossible Burger 2.0 has reached parity with meat-based burgers. It seems unlikely that they'll just stop innovating, so they might eventually produce a soy-based burger that tastes better than meat at the same price. If that happens, it's game over for meat.
- cr0sh 8y agoIt'll still be a burger - or ground burger product. What if I want a well-marbled aged beef ribeye? Or if I want to smoke a pork shoulder or brisket? Those kinds of products are going to take some time before they become manufactured from plant-based sources (or before they are "grown" - indeed, the first versions of that nature are likely to be too lean, which will be a real problem, especially for taste and texture).
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoWe have them in local joints - at a 50% premium. Not gonna take over at that price.
- Vinnl 8y agoWe're so far from that being even close to a problem that I feel it's a bit disingenuous to see it repeated so often when vegetarianism comes up. There's a whole lot of meat we can cut out of our diets without any of that becoming a problem. (And of course, if the soy that is currently fed to cattle is fed to humans directly, we can feed quite a few more humans from that than that cattle currently can, without needing to use more resources. That's not to say it does not come with its own problems, but they're unlikely to be as severe as the ones we get with meat anytime soon.)
- alangpierce 8y agoPlant-based foods are almost always significantly more efficient to produce than meat since you no longer need to grow all of the food to feed an animal for its entire life. From another article ( https://www.cnet.com/news/impossible-burger-2-0-tastes-like-beef-really/ https://www.cnet.com/news/impossible-burger-2-0-tastes-like-... ): > But Impossible Foods can produce a burger using a fourth of the water and less than 4 percent of the land -- and emit one-tenth of the greenhouse gases -- than a conventional burger, Brown said. So yeah, we might still destroy forests to make veggie burgers, but it'll be 1/25th of the forest destruction (if you believe the numbers).
- tptacek 8y agoIt's easy to win the argument that plant-based foods are more efficient to mass-produce than CAFO meat, but you might need to be careful generalizing; pigs and chickens fed forage and scrap are supposedly pretty efficient as well. (I have no idea if there's an efficient way to scale beef).
- hundt 8y ago> I have no idea if there's an efficient way to scale beef If you're interested, https://twitter.com/drsplace https://twitter.com/drsplace is a good follow. She writes and cites a lot on this topic (because she is employed by the beef industry).
- firethief 8y agoEfficiency and scalability are not the same thing. Does forage not have high land requirement? If there were a massive demand for scrap, would it be met by something other than scrap farming?
- tptacek 8y agoNo, the point of forage is that it does not spend arable land generating crops for livestock. That's the meaning of the term.
- epanchin 8y ago
- 24gttghh 8y agoI've been under the impression that plant-based proteins take up less land than does animal-derived protein[0][1][2]. I could go on with the citations. So yes, replacing everything with plant-based protein would be vastly better. Edit: Vastly better than Beef* [0]https://www.wri.org/resources/charts-graphs/animal-based-foods-are-more-resource-intensive-plant-based-foods https://www.wri.org/resources/charts-graphs/animal-based-foo... [1]https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you-eat/protein/#protein-planet https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you... [2]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5899434/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5899434/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mistercow 8y agoUnless the Impossible Burger is exceptionally inefficient to produce, that's still a huge win. An acre of land can produce about twenty times as much edible protein from soy as from beef.
- PhasmaFelis 8y ago> trying to replace everything with vegetable stuff is not going to work in the long run. I'm not sure what you think the alternative is. People need to eat.
- cr0sh 8y agoMaybe cattle farming (plus fertilizer and methane recovery) in near-Earth orbit O'Neill Cylinders will be the answer?