3 ms·
Voting with your dollars doesn't work in all cases. Possibly not even in most cases. Markets aren't that transparent, and more importantly, you buy based on the
by mcv 8y ago
Voting with your dollars doesn't work in all cases. Possibly not even in most cases. Markets aren't that transparent, and more importantly, you buy based on the company's past behaviour, whereas if your product requires support, it's their future behaviour that matters to you. You buy based on past product quality, but current product quality is what matters.
You may buy a product from a great company with excellent support, and then a hedge fund comes along and fucks up that company for some quick profit, and you're screwed.
On top of that: vendor lock-in. Switching to a different platform can be hard and expensive, no matter how much you want to.
Of course most smart companies with long-term vision listen to their customers, but plenty of companies don't. Many great companies have been ruined for short-term profit for either their executives or their investors.
And the same is true for employees: a lot of people can't afford to leave their job. They've got mouths to feed. And besides, in their next job, they might be just as powerless.
Ultimately, the skewed division of power is not always good for companies, and it enables the people holding that power to enrich themselves at the cost of other stakeholders.
- repsilat 8y agoI totally agree that market solutions aren't perfect. I alluded to some legal fixes in place, but there are of course many others, some of which address concerns you raised -- fitness for purpose, abuse of market power, varying levels of employee protection and representation depending on jurisdiction. These things are clearly patches, though. The logic of the system is that companies operate on the behalf of their owners, with some sharp edges filed off to handle perverse incentives. I guess this organisation wasn't chosen for its competitive advantage (probably rather just a legal&historical accident) but it seems to be doing better than anything else we've tried -- worker co-ops, non-profits etc.