3 ms·
> censorship resistant, pseudonymous e-cash/e-gold (Bitcoin) Bitcoin not only doesn’t deliver on those claims, it’s actively dangerous because it leaves an imm
by acdha 8y ago
> censorship resistant, pseudonymous e-cash/e-gold (Bitcoin)
Bitcoin not only doesn’t deliver on those claims, it’s actively dangerous because it leaves an immutable public record of your activities, as numerous court cases have shown. There’s a reason why the mob doesn’t publish their ledgers.
“Censorship resistant” is also a complex claim since the network is trivially blocked as a whole, and the inability to comply with legal demands means that anyone legitimate faces risks which will encourage them to stop participating, reducing the defense for allowing it at all and removing the traffic everyone else is hoping to hide behind.
- jki275 8y agoHe said pseudonymous, not anonymous... It's censorship resistant in its use. It only becomes an issue in terms of actually cashing out -- but that's not necessarily required.
- acdha 8y ago> He said pseudonymous, not anonymous... That's why I said it's dangerous: telling people a word which sounds like anonymous but actually means “irrepudiable proof of identity” is setting them up to make decisions under the belief that they are closer to anonymous than they actually are. Given how proponents like to proclaim benefits for people in countries with repressive governments, that's just irresponsible. > It's censorship resistant in its use. It only becomes an issue in terms of actually cashing out -- but that's not necessarily required. What does that even mean? A government can block it easily because the design requires you to be on the network and the lack of anonymity means that anyone who attempts to bypass those restrictions has valid reasons to fear reprisal.
- jki275 8y agoWell, they're two concepts with quite different meanings -- I'm not sure how you do better than explaining it that way. I've always explained bitcoin that way, and I think most people understand it that way now. "the network" is a concept that doesn't necessarily mean "the public internet". Also, it really doesn't require everyone to be on the network -- it requires a network to exist. And pseudonymity can be "good enough". The point was that the entire ecosystem can exist independent of cashing it out to fiat -- that point can be somewhat controlled, but it's not necessarily required.
- acdha 8y ago> pseudonymity can be "good enough". Which is to say, it's not good enough for anything which matters, especially in any case where censorship is a relevant concern. > "the network" is a concept that doesn't necessarily mean "the public internet". Also, it really doesn't require everyone to be on the network -- it requires a network to exist. This is similarly meaningless: if you're talking Bitcoin, you're by definition saying you need to be on the regular internet and if you're running some private network you either have the exact same problems with trust & monitoring or you don't need a blockchain in the first place because you have some other trusted communications channel.
- jki275 8y agoNo, it's good enough if precautions are taken. If you apply a moderate amount of care, your identity is not hard to protect when using it. There are a variety of ways to have private transactions across either the public internet or other networks. There are a variety of coins that use tor, for instance. It doesn't have to be bitcoin either. My point was that if you can avoid cashing out to fiat using well known gateways, anonymity isn't difficult to preserve. It only becomes an anonymity problem if you are careless or if you cash out using known KYCd gateways.
- acdha 8y ago> It only becomes an anonymity problem if you are careless or if you cash out using known KYCd gateways. This means you can't use it for currency transactions, with anyone you don't trust, or on any system which might be compromised by the authorities you're trying to evade. If you ever make a mistake, all of that not only won't help you but will be strong evidence of intention. There are very few threat models where “use cash” is not a much safer answer.
- jki275 8y agoThat's not what that means. It means you need to operate inside the cryptocurrency ecosystem instead of counting on cashing out all the time, or you simply use any of the many non-regulated means to cash in and out of the ecosystem. That's becoming more and more possible to do.